Quote from @Juan Lizarazo:
Hello beautiful community! In the ever-evolving landscape of investments, I'm curious to hear about the strategies that savvy investors are currently employing. I am navigating the financing of a deal via a DSCR loan and have encountered an intriguing decision point.
The options I am presented with are as follows:
- 1. Opt for an interest rate of 9.125%, which would result in decreased cash flow and a larger payment amount, with a lesser contribution towards principal. However, this option provides the advantage of only a 1% prepayment penalty for the first five years.
- 2. Choose an interest rate of 8.5% (no point buydown) but accompanied by a steeper 5% prepayment penalty, which reduces by 1% annually. The core distinction between these two options, other than the interest rate, lies in the varying prepayment penalty scales: 4% more for the first year, 3% for the second, and so on.
With the latter option, my cash flow is healthier in the present context. Although one might think of refinancing as a viable approach when rates drop, predicting such shifts in the financial terrain is, unfortunately, beyond our skills—it could be a year or even a decade away.
I would love to gain insights into how many of you are structuring your financing in today's market. I am inclined towards the option offering a lower rate, as it provides a superior cash flow in the present and future, I will make more money starting today and my tenants will pay off more principal sooner. Nonetheless, should I choose to refinance within the next five years, penalties will invariably factor in, and thus any refinancing would necessitate a significantly more favorable rate to make it worthwhile.
Your valuable perspective is greatly appreciated. Thank you in advance for your insights!
I just bought 3 properties on a similar structure. 3yr ARM with prepayment penalties of 3%, 2%, and 1%. The reality is that if rates came down low enough in the next 2 years it would be worth the penalty to Refi out. The odds of rates coming down significantly in the next 2 years is very low regardless of what all the optimists are saying. You can look at all the Fed reports and see that they are higher for longer. Everyone who said last year that rates would come down by Q4 of this year was absolutely wrong, and ignored everything the Fed said it would be doing to hype people into buying now and Refi later. The 10yr Treasury prices are also a concern for lower rates being a reality.
My lender will also not charge a prepay penalty if I Refi with them, the penalty only happens if I take my loan to another lender. They just want to keep your business in house because they will make money on the new loan origination and then the start of a fresh loan even at a lower rate.