I really find this topic interesting and I think about it every time I read an article telling us that we will never be able to retire.
Yes, I am maxing out my company sponsored & matched roth 401k and seperate individual Roth IRA, but Im also scraping together as much as I can to get into as many good rental properties as I can now.
The way I see it, I would rather shell out 5, $30k down payments for single family houses and collect $8,500.00/mo in rent rather than build up my 401k to $1MM and get maybe half of that if you are only taking out interest.
The difference in out of pocket outlay for the different routes is absolutely staggering and I can't understand why more people aren't going this route.
Of course diversification is important and its hard to argue with a company match so I will continue down that path, but for a 26 year old, Im much more eager to purchase even 5-10 single family homes and pay them off over the next twenty years to enjoy an early retirement. One that I couldn't dream if it was only to be funded by my 401k.
The snowball effect that can be created from rental real estate, if you do it correctly, dwarfs everything else by a wide margin.
Im glad more people are considering it because I was beginning to think I was missing something. Its too obvious to me.
I would greatly hesistate to take the tax and penalty hit. I would just leave that amount and withdraw it when he can and in the mean time take the funds he would have been contributing to account in excess of gaining the company match and put it towards real estate. Sounds like he already has a great head start, it shouldn't take a whole lot more for him to finish it off. It wouldn't take a hail mary like cashing in his 401k.