@David Kuhlke
Before talking cap rate, you need to clean up your underwriting.
-You can get the exact tax number by going on the auditors site and calculating the assessed value. If you are in a state where the property is reassessed at sale then plug the tax rate in based on your purchase price.
-insurance looks high at 1,000/unit/yr. I’ve seen this around 175-275/unit/yr in the Midwest - granted for larger deal sizes.
-capex - you should itemize your capex budget based on the condition of the apartments. If they need a lot of repairs best to get them knocked out early and with financing so it doesn’t burn a hole in your CF.
-Repairs and Maintenance is high but it looks like you could be including other stuff in here.
Overall, a 4.2 cap is very aggressive especially using proforma numbers. You would want to see how the property has been operating for the past year and get an idea what the trailing cap is. If there is opportunity to push rents or if the property is not being managed well, you may be able to see that with a good operation you can improve the revenue decrease expenses which will bring your cap rate up. If there is upside then that justifies the compressed cap rate.