@David Hines
How are you sir?
I saw that thread from yesterday you referred to up there. Brutal! Honestly, though, those types of posts are exactly what BP is for: information, education, and from time to time, debate.
I do agree with you regarding your assessment of wholesalers, as a whole. It is true that most of the wholesalers that I receive leads from are "wholesalers" just marking up other wholesalers fees on the same property and redistributing them - meaning they don't even have the deal under contract, yet they're advertising it as if they do. It's rare that they are educated on rehab costs and selecting accurate comparables, and even more rare to be licensed brokers.
I've seen the guys who give you the home with the $500,000 ARV that they're selling for $390,000 but it only needs $15,000 in work (that should hardly cover paint).
Then there are the ones that live in Alabama, yet they're sending you homes in Chicago. You know the ones that have never been to Chicago? Yet they're trying to sell me on a home that they "know" is a deal. Again, most likely found from another wholesaler and then marked up and redistributed.
The list goes on.
However, I have had great business relationships with individuals that provided immense value because they brought actual deals to the table.
Believe it or not, if you ask any major player out there who's actually flipping properties, most of them will tell you their #1 issue is not raising money, or managing rehabs, or even re-selling the homes after repairs. The biggest issue is keeping their pipeline full of homes that will get them good returns on their money. They'll also tell you that not every deal needs to be a "home run". A couple base hits here and there, and the occasional home run is more than fine.
So, if any investor does find a great bird-dog, agent/broker, probate attorney, or wholesaler that can provide actual deals, I think that adds tremendous value. Ethics, knowledge, and competency are the only 3 requirements. I don't care who the deal comes from at that point. A deal is a deal - so long as those three requirements are met, of course.
So:
My OPINION - lead sources are super valuable. The good ones, at least.
My EXPERIENCE - most lead sources aren't reliable. The deals aren't steep enough to make an investor profit. Rehabbers have to dig through 100 pieces of trash to find the handful of diamonds in the rough.
I guess it really comes down to personality. If you can find a good wholesaler, who has the property under contract, who is knowledgable about the market, who's rehab numbers are reasonable, and who's ethical in their dealings, you've got a keeper.
However, just like sorting through 100 leads to find the 5 good ones, you'll need to sort through 100 lead sources to find the 5 good ones as well.
Good luck, sir.