Mark,
If you'll reread my post, I stated that it is "likely" a better deal. I don't know the taxes and insurance on his proposed property to compare the true cash flow. I stand by my original statement.
There 1000 properties in Southwest Jackson MS that will cash flow like crazy...I can pick them up for 5-10k...I haven't bought any of them b/c they are in horrible areas. You need to buy a bunch or don't play in there at all. On paper these are better investments...but in REALITY they are not. Location, Location, Location.
The original poster is completing his 3rd deal...I wouldn't buy a duplex unless the area and cash flow was significantly higher vs a comparable SFR. You can market a duplex to 5% of the population. You can market a SFR to 100%.
I am sales manager with Bank of America Home Loans. It is hard to get financing on anything especially if it's more than 1 unit.
He might not like my property, but it would be a much wiser investment than the current choice he has. We have done a lot of NOO loans in Jackson for Cali investors...they are always buying in the wrong areas. It appears to be a deal b/c the price is so low...But they are a dime a dozen like that in S. Jackson.
Northeast Jackson is a different story. But even parts of NE jackson aren't good. I buy properties in areas I would live in. And my wife won't let me just live anywhere.
Location, exit strategy, appraised value, and cash flow should all be taken into consideration.
I am agreement that he should probably pass on this deal.