@Jason Mak I agree. I couldn't find an eviction, just the collections, so I'm wondering if it was for damages, or maybe they moved prior to the formal eviction. There was also a civil judgement award to someone that appeared to be a property manager when I Google'd him. I'm sure there's so much more to the story, but the only story I got was 'I was young and stupid'. We actually signed the lease with someone else on Saturday.
@Matt Sicignano I actually told the applicant past performance is an indicator of future performance. I didn't expect them to bite on paying the former landlord, but if they did, I would have been happy for the landlord. I use a scoring system but it boils down to having a reasonable expectation that I'll collect the rent. That's my gauge when screening.
@Marcia Maynard Great list of factors. I read recently that you should deny more applicants than you approve. That's certainly been my track record over the past week.
@Matthew Paul Hadn't thought of that. And they were barely meeting our minimum 3x rent requirement for income!
@Kimberly T. I got an applicant's credit report back yesterday and the score was over 550. I did a two-step in the middle of the living room floor. My family thought I was nuts! Unfortunately I don't think she's going to take the unit. And with the other one leased on Saturday, this is our last vacancy.