I am in a similar situation with 3 properties. I understand that everyone's situation is different. But from a perspective of growing my portfolio, at what point do you cash out to redeploy? One of my properties is the coveted 2%er and the other is just shy of the 1.75% mark. I have recouped all funds that were invested in both and cash flow $1200 combined. The other is a work in progress. Realistically I could pullout $100k out of 2 and still beat the stock market on my numbers. I could pick up 2-3 houses in my area with those funds and have long term leverage in place. Now with 5-6 units my cash flow would be about $1900 net (not a bad move). But with the market in my area being fairly high, a reset could hurt! As I am typing this I am drawing my own conclusion... Equity is not a bad thing. Especially when rentals are apart of your retirement portfolio. Yes, you MIGHT cash flow more when funds are redeployed, but you own less of what you already worked for (ie. putting more leverage on a property).