Hi Folks,
I have a rental house in Independence, MO near the high school. I purchased in 2016 and did some repairs / make-ready work myself. It's been rented and producing well until late May when there was a fire in the house. The fire dept and insurance investigators were not able to determine a cause of the fire. I (probably unwisely, certainly unfortunately) had the house insured for a fixed amount of coverage at $60,000 which is about what I have invested in the property. My rationale was to protect my investment from common occurrences but not necessarily be able to rebuild the house in the event of a catastrophe (not expecting a catastrophe). That was probably a mistake but that's history and it's not what i want to discuss right now.
Market value for the house was probably somewhere around $90-100k. It was renting for just under $1,000 on a 2 year lease. If i rebuild and it's got new appliances and finishes it might pull in a little more.
Repair costs will probably be $100k or more. I've got one rough estimate in from a contractor and another should be coming in soon.
I would consider demolishing the house and selling the lot if that is the more financially prudent way to go. I'd also consider selling as-is. I have periodically received yellow letters or "I buy houses!" postcards and I called the most recent guy (maybe a site member?) and he's going to take a look at the house and let me know what he can offer for it.
How would you all decide how to proceed with this situation? Any advice or recommendations for me?
I think i'll do my best to put together a spreadsheet modeling the financial outcome of various scenarios
1. Use insurance money and invest additional cash to repair house and rent it back out. It will now have a lower return due to having more invested, but may still be a reasonable investment.
2. Sell as-is. Depends on what sort of price i can get for it
3. Demolish and sell lot. Not sure what it would cost to demolish. I've heard $6-8k from someone at the city, and i heard $20k thrown out by a contractor. Then there's the issue of selling a bare lot in a fairly low-value neighborhood, would it even be sellable?
4. ??? Probably lots of things i haven't thought of.
Thanks for any responses!