I see your criteria, but I would strongly consider looking at Nevada. It’s closest to your location. Nevada has the third lowest property taxes in the nation, no state income tax and very landlord friendly laws. No offense to Ohio but they are usually in the top 10 most expensive states for property taxes, along with Texas. Reno is considerably less expensive as an entry point compared to CA.
I'm helping a lot of CA investors discover Reno and I'm curious on why Nevada wouldn't even be a consideration? We have severe land constraints, and Tesla is about to expand Giga Nevada to include the Tesla Semi factory which will lead to more rent and home appreciation. Our low unemployment is driving up housing prices from a lull we have been in for 18 months and we continue to have population migration from NorCal and the most expensive area in the nation, the Bay Area. Our market dynamics are optimal for real estate investing either SFR or Multifamily.