My percentages were simply to show yall how much I was taking for each item. Of course the percentages coincide with what the repairs and cleaning actually cost me. I did not just say "Humm, I think I'll charge 16% for that.". I got a new deposit because it was a brand new lease. Not an extension. Deposit amount did change (went up). I am not planning on splitting up the amount back to each tenant. They paid me with one deposit check so I plan on supplying them with one refund check and it is up to them to determine who gets what. This is the first problem I have ever had with them in the past year and a half. Also, the problem is wI think tenant 1, who is the one moving out. Tenant 2 who is staying seems to understand the cleaning fee and has no problem paying it from what I can tell.
I know now I should not talk to the parent but like I said, these are our first tenants in our first rental and I am trying to learn as I go without getting sued in the process.
The mother and tenant 1 are supposed to come clean and make repairs tonight and I am to go inspect afterward. My biggest concern now is if it is not clean to my (aka my wifes) standards and we still have to charge a cleaning fee. At this point, for such a small amount of money, if that happens we might just eat it and pay it ourselves. We make enough on the rental to cover that no problem and I don't believe it is worth a half day off work dealing with court.