Originally posted by @Brent Coombs:
@Tim Vecchioni, I agree with @Erik Kubec about the purpose of refinancing. You would normally be borrowing MORE (so long as it still cash flowed SOME) - not paying three and a half years worth of PMI (plus refi fees) up front just so the PMI could be removed thereafter!
So yes, I believe you're right to "guess it wouldn't make sense if we refi then sell when he leaves if in 2 years since we would lose all the money from the refi".
ie. Sell. (Did I suggest that already?)...
Well, I am looking at it like this. The home is in one of the better neighborhoods in the Pasadena area. It is in great condition. It would cost say $2,850 + $6,000 out of pocket to refinance down to the $184k we need to be for no PMI. The house at that point would be cash flowing $68 a month as well as accruing equity for as long as we have it. So how long, would it take to make back the $8,850? Well, that would be 130 months at $68, or 10 years. But within those 10 years, how much equity has the property gained?
The second option is to sell in say 2 years. We will have about $188k left on the loan and say best case scenario we sell for the $230k. Let's just assume 7% to be average for closing costs which would be right around $16k. That leaves us with $214k minus the $188k, which is $26k in profit. Not bad! But also not that great for selling off a property after 7 years.
I guess my argument to keep it would be that we plan to keep it for a long time until the equity really starts to dip in our favor.
My argument for selling it is that we could use the profit to really look for a great deal instead of holding onto this at a smaller cash flow. Although it is a cash flow on top of all the expense after the refinance, which is always a plus!
Edit - Just saw you edited your post with that last comment. Yes, that is the end goal! But some of us don't have the luxury to get into the deals like others! Some of us have to keep these small wins to keep our feet wet! Plus as long as it is paying for itself, say 30 years down the road. It will be worth a lot more than the possible $26k we would be selling it for now!