@Stuart Udis I'll agree with your post for the majority people. Of course there are successful students also but for most, it's not going to work. My former Mentor/Coach told me only about 4% of all students ever do anything, and only about 2-3% do it well.
After I heard this I wondered how could the educators really know who will succeed and who will not? I was blown away when I saw the ones I was sure would, and didn't. Then others I didn't see it and they killed it in syndications (and still are). So I don't blame the educators for taking students.
I concluded it's "buyer beware". Which is exactly what your post is about. Good job.
I have a theory I've been working on for years and I still don't know how to articulate it very well. But here it goes:
I believe there are many people who are Smart, Good Savers (so they have funds), Responsible, Highly Regarded in Their Work. But none of that makes them "Entrepreneurial". And I believe this is the key.
I've been telling people for years that successful real estate investing is a Highly Entrepreneurial Endeavor. Most people don't really even know what this means. It does not mean someone who opens a business, and doesn't necessarily mean your created or invented something new.
It means you are First a Visionary, and Second willing to take the risk.
Many people who are responsible, got a great job, saved money, and then want to run a real estate business - are very risk averse (opposite of Entrepreneurism). So they don't do deals.
So what's the answer? For many of you who are chasing what Stuart is saying, you are probably better suited to be an LP in a professionals syndication (being careful to vet them of course), than to set out to become the GP.