Hi @Tim Mangold , my husband and I are also newbies. We recently shelled out $300 for an LLC, and I think it was the next day that I read on the forums that it was probably an unnecessary expense, at least initially.
The problem is that if you put a property under the ownership of an LLC, a bank won't loan you money on it (initial mortgage or refinance). Supposedly, your LLC hasn't established credit yet, so the bank won't loan it money. I haven't yet researched how exactly the LLC would go about establishing credit.
An alternate suggestion I saw was to carry a large umbrella insurance policy (perhaps $5 million) to protect your assets from lawsuits.
Also, I know it's different in each state, but in my state (Texas), it would have been a total waste of money to pay an attorney or a legal website to set up the LLC. It's just an application form that you fill out on the state's website and give them your credit card # to pay for it. What you do once you have the LLC is another matter, of course, and expert advice could be very beneficial!