Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Tim Shin

Tim Shin has started 22 posts and replied 239 times.

Post: Can a " Wholesaler" be a crook with a contract?

Tim ShinPosted
  • Investor
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 242
  • Votes 81
Originally posted by @Carolyn Morales:
Originally posted by @Tim Shin:
Originally posted by @Carolyn Morales:
Originally posted by @Michaela G.:
Originally posted by @Carolyn Morales:

What some consider "wholesaling" is actually illegal in some states. How long has this term been used in RE markets? Better yet, The term ," Wholetaling" is a modern word made up to try to validate resales from a person with no no credentials and no regulations. I think there should be regulations and credentials required to "wholesale or wholetail" 

 Why? If someone is a principal in the transaction, they should have every right to sell their own property. You don't have to buy it. And if nobody's buying, then it doesn't fit the market they're trying to connect with. 

But to say that nobody should be allowed to sell their own houses plays right into the pocket of real estate agents, who don't want investors to cut them out. 

Sure there are crooks, just like in every industry, but how fair is it to say that nobody should be able to do something, because some misuse their rights?

 That is fair enough. I just have not yet encountered a reputable wholesaler in action.

To put someone's property on contract for months and tie it up and not actually buy and close on it, Is not really owning the property. To remarket from mls is shady in my opinion, while that mls listing now says "pending" is because a so called wholesaler is now marketing to his REI local meet up as a wholesale property. Is this what we should expect of a reputable wholesaler?

 What difference does it make to you if a seller decides to sell the property to a wholesaler and the wholesaler goes to market it? If it's a good deal it won't be pending for months. If they've represented the deal to the seller as such where the seller understands the wholesaler is seeking a new buyer why would you insist that the seller not behave as they want? In my opinion a reputable wholesaler could get a property under contract at significant discount and sell it to the right investor at a discount from market. This works well with properties that are not selling for distress or poor real estate agency. Often they are represented by crooked agents who don't have their interests at heart. I've seen agents fend off full price buyers so they could capture the deal from their client at a discount..

Still there is a reason some title companies will not do double closings and a reason. Wholsalkig in this manner is illegal in some states..

 If it's illegal, then yes they should not be doing it that way. However, in many states it's not illegal and therefore legitimate. That's like saying in some states it's illegal to 

against the law for a woman to drive a car in Main Street unless her husband is walking in front of the car waving a red flag (Waynesboro, Virginia)

http://justsomething.co/the-22-most-ridiculous-us-laws-still-in-effect-today-2/2/

Post: Can a " Wholesaler" be a crook with a contract?

Tim ShinPosted
  • Investor
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 242
  • Votes 81

Why do they have to close first? Why not just close both at the same time? What's the difference if it happens in less than 30days and everyone is happy?

Post: Can a " Wholesaler" be a crook with a contract?

Tim ShinPosted
  • Investor
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 242
  • Votes 81
Originally posted by @Carolyn Morales:
Originally posted by @Michaela G.:
Originally posted by @Carolyn Morales:

What some consider "wholesaling" is actually illegal in some states. How long has this term been used in RE markets? Better yet, The term ," Wholetaling" is a modern word made up to try to validate resales from a person with no no credentials and no regulations. I think there should be regulations and credentials required to "wholesale or wholetail" 

 Why? If someone is a principal in the transaction, they should have every right to sell their own property. You don't have to buy it. And if nobody's buying, then it doesn't fit the market they're trying to connect with. 

But to say that nobody should be allowed to sell their own houses plays right into the pocket of real estate agents, who don't want investors to cut them out. 

Sure there are crooks, just like in every industry, but how fair is it to say that nobody should be able to do something, because some misuse their rights?

 That is fair enough. I just have not yet encountered a reputable wholesaler in action.

To put someone's property on contract for months and tie it up and not actually buy and close on it, Is not really owning the property. To remarket from mls is shady in my opinion, while that mls listing now says "pending" is because a so called wholesaler is now marketing to his REI local meet up as a wholesale property. Is this what we should expect of a reputable wholesaler?

 What difference does it make to you if a seller decides to sell the property to a wholesaler and the wholesaler goes to market it? If it's a good deal it won't be pending for months. If they've represented the deal to the seller as such where the seller understands the wholesaler is seeking a new buyer why would you insist that the seller not behave as they want? In my opinion a reputable wholesaler could get a property under contract at significant discount and sell it to the right investor at a discount from market. This works well with properties that are not selling for distress or poor real estate agency. Often they are represented by crooked agents who don't have their interests at heart. I've seen agents fend off full price buyers so they could capture the deal from their client at a discount. 

Post: Can a " Wholesaler" be a crook with a contract?

Tim ShinPosted
  • Investor
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 242
  • Votes 81
Originally posted by @Pyrrha Rivers:
Originally posted by @Tim Shin:
@Lee Scarlett

I agree. This is what you should be considering. While some wholesalers may be crooked and will try to wholesale other people's deals without having a contract, the legitimate wholesaler can get a good bargain on the MLS from a seller if the conditions are right. A good and legitimate wholesaler provides a discounted deal to the end buyer where they will make money off it. Your job as a wholesaler is to provide awesome deals. You get an awesome deal from the MLS at discount and offer that to investors BELOW MARKET. That's the point and the only way you should offer a wholesale deal. Wholetailing is a different story.

I have yet to experience a "Wholesaler" bring me an MLS deal at a discount. I've had ont bring me a deal at $10 over the listed price and another at $14K over. What work exactly am I expected to compensate them for? Does not foster trust.

I totally agree with those who say the wholesaler finds great deals, calculate the rehab cost, ARV, mark up and still present them at good value to the investor.

I'm waiting for THAT wholesaler!

 I'm not sure where you're located but here in Houston we've got plenty of both reputable and both crooked wholesalers. However, my last couple o deals never made it to blast out to my buyer's list or people I don't know well because I have networked with dependable buyers who know I will give them a good deal and who have gotten over how much I might make on it. They don't care if I make $5000 or $36,000 if they're making $100,000. I use conservative numbers which benefit the end buyer. 

I will not, however, hold a buyer's hand through doing their own due diligence. I'll accommodate them but I'm not going to do it for them. 

My sellers love me because they have great customer experiences where I treat them as king/queen and will do what it takes to solve THEIR problem first. I'm honest with them in letting them know what their property could sell for if they put all the repairs in and listed it with an agent. I will even suggest agents who will help them. But often repairs are beyond them and I will help them close within 30 days unless they have title issues. (One deal took us 6 months because of their title). I let them know up front it's likely I will sell their property to another investor. I don't want to be rehabber/flipper but if there is a deal that I can't resist I might become one for it. 

This all results in a great, discounted deal for the end buyer.

I understand your frustrations though, I see the bad wholesale listings come through to me. 

Post: Can a " Wholesaler" be a crook with a contract?

Tim ShinPosted
  • Investor
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 242
  • Votes 81
Originally posted by @Sean Cole:

Wow!

To answer the original question, of course a wholesaler can me a crook with a contract, but I don't see how their acquisition source matters.

Most real estate investors have full time jobs and aren't able to go see a property at the drop of a hat during the work day. So the service that the wholesaler is providing on MLS deals is a fixed price for the house (no highest & best), a full set of comps to justify ARV, a rehab budget, contractor referrals, etc., etc., etc. If a house comes on the MLS at 10am and the seller has clearly listed it below what it should be worth as-is, and I go run and get ANOTHER discount on top of that and then sell it to you at a price that you're happy with, what's the problem? You could've been in multiples or never even had a chance because someone else snagged it first.

Some folks get wrapped up in who's making how much on each deal.  Others say they don't care how much the wholesaler makes until they find out the guy is making "too much."  Most don't care and just want deals.

Sentiments like this are why I started this post:  https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/311/topics/274123-should-we-use-a-different-term-for-professional-wholesalers

I agree. This is what you should be considering. While some wholesalers may be crooked and will try to wholesale other people's deals without having a contract, the legitimate wholesaler can get a good bargain on the MLS from a seller if the conditions are right. A good and legitimate wholesaler provides a discounted deal to the end buyer where they will make money off it. Your job as a wholesaler is to provide awesome deals. You get an awesome deal from the MLS at discount and offer that to investors BELOW MARKET. That's the point and the only way you should offer a wholesale deal. Wholetailing is a different story.

Post: My First Deal: SFH Buy & Hold Rental in Houston

Tim ShinPosted
  • Investor
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 242
  • Votes 81

@iman yu

Get congratulations! I love going to RICH on deal a minute nights. Is that the event where you picked it up? Can you give us some more details? Neighborhood, ARV, cost of repairs, projected expenses? I'd love to know more juicy detail. Helpful!

Post: Question about Fifth Ward, Houston Market

Tim ShinPosted
  • Investor
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 242
  • Votes 81
Originally posted by @Jeffrey H.:

@Tim Shin I really like the BP calculator for back of the envelope high level estimate, but you're right that every property will have different expense ratios.

For example - one of my rentals is a brick home, energy efficient with an older A/C unit.  One of the other rentals has clapboard wooden exterior siding and window units for A/C.  Clearly my expenses for the wooden siding maintenance will be higher than brick as will need to repaint and touch up every 5 years or less, and the service for the window units will likely be less (especially since my lease states the tenants are responsible for them along with appliance repairs under $150 for that rental) along with them being cheap to replace and fairly serviceable.

You have to look at each component of a given property and estimate the maintenance for it based on what you know, what you have seen as best practice here, ways you can minimize or avoid the expense, and based on quotes that you get from contractors as part of your diligence period.  Every home is different, and you use the BP calculator as your starting point.  After you have done a walkthrough and taken pictures of everything you should be able to firm this up and make an intelligent offer that reflects reality.  Then get your pro forma very precise during diligence before close.

Hope this helps.

 Thanks! What %s do you use to filter your properties for more in depth analysis? Am I right to think that maintenance % in the Heights for $3000/mo rent should be lower than 5th Ward $1000/mo? If they were both 10% you'd be talking about needing $300/mo in maintenance savings just for being in the Heights rather than $100/mo in the 5th Ward. 

Post: Question about Fifth Ward, Houston Market

Tim ShinPosted
  • Investor
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 242
  • Votes 81

What %s do you use to filter your properties for more in depth analysis? 

Post: wholesale

Tim ShinPosted
  • Investor
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 242
  • Votes 81
Originally posted by @Jasmine Anderson:

I don't know of any groups that ONLY talk about wholesaling (and if there is one they are probably trying to sell you something), but there are a lot of well versed groups that meet in the city. A few are REIA/ RENC, RICH Club, Lifestyles unlimited. Those are clubs that offer memberships, but you can also find a lot of meetups around town that will put you in a room with a lot of knowledgeable people that can help with wholesaling questions and any other questions that you may have. You can do a BP search for "Houston Meetups" and you'll find meetup groups that easily.

I really recommend going to as many events as you can and you'll be sure to find wholesalers that can help guide you. You may also even decide that you're interested in a different niche that fits you better. 

Just be sure to be open to going to all events and don't limit yourself to only seeking out council for wholesaling. 

Hope this helps!

 I second this message! You'll find some of us around those meet ups in the city and you can ask about it. There was a wholesaling panel not to long ago at RICH that I think you missed but apparently it got heated... 

Post: Anyone use Dohardmoney.com to fund a deal? Your experience?

Tim ShinPosted
  • Investor
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 242
  • Votes 81
Originally posted by @Jessica Martin:

@Jacque Fairbourn this is Jeremy I have actually already contacted your company and was speaking with a Erik Thompson. I spoke with him on Friday. We spoke for several minutes and he told me he would call me back in 10 min, I waited around for 30 min the call never came. So I called back today and was advised he would be given the message to call me back. Again here we are end of day and no phone call and no emails. Which led me to doing some research on the company. None of which has been good by any means To some people this is no big deal but to me my word is my bond and if you can simply call me back how can I believe anything else that comes from him. This is very serious stuff and a lot of money at stake. I don't have a ton of money to just throw around and then only have it taken and then not get funded.

 Hey Jeremy and Jessica, let us know how this goes for you! My wife and I might try working with these guys if you have a good experience.