Quote from @Mark Munson:
Hi @Tim Braun
I would call as many lenders as you can and just make apples to apples comparisons. One question you need to ask is what is your rate lock policy? You want the lender to lock your rate once they get your application and credit pulled, so essentially day one. If they float your rate, I would look elsewhere. You want your rate locked for 30 days or more to avoid it changing on you during underwriting. If a full appraisal is required, you should be paying that cost directly to the Appraisal Management Company, not the lender. Some lenders use that as a profit center and up-charge you. Also, aim for a 3-year or less prepayment penalty, that will give you the flexibility to refinance when rates drop (if they do) after year 3. Ask about a buy down to get a lower rate and if that can be rolled into the loan, there are many lenders that can offer that if you want it. Look at 40-year options with interest only periods at the front end, that can help maximize cash-flow until you potentially refinance when rates come down. Lastly, if the loan amount exceeds $150k, I wouldn't pay origination fees above 2% if you have 720+ credit. The only costs to the loan, aside from the appraisal, should be the origination fee and the underwriting/processing fee. Make sure you get full loan summaries from the broker or lender, not soft quotes. Reach out if you need any help.
Thanks Mark! Lots of good tips here, I'm going to add them to my lender interview script so I don't forget.
I did have one HML who started taking me for a ride. When we started getting the deal done it was one rate, then the home became "rural" so it was another rate, then they had to get a different partner so the rate changed again... 2 months later I said thanks but no thanks.
And I'm glad you pointed out the 40 year interest only. I was on the phone with a lender yesterday and they mentioned it and immediately I thought it sounded a little risky, but now I can see how that could be useful (as long as I'm not doing that on every property I acquire I think - I am just getting started).
My big issue right now is finding a DSCR product in NY. I still have a month and a half before the remodel is finished, so I have some time but I wanted to get going early.