Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Thomas Rutkowski

Thomas Rutkowski has started 20 posts and replied 796 times.

Post: What does diversification look like to you!?

Thomas Rutkowski
#5 Personal Finance Contributor
Posted
  • Financial Advisor
  • Boynton Beach, FL
  • Posts 813
  • Votes 788
Quote from @Mike S.:
Quote from @V.G Jason:

 No, life insurance in all forms is an incredibly stupid vehicle to put money in. 

I strongly disagree with you. A properly structured cash value permanent life insurance can be an incredible tool in your wealth building strategy. You obviously have not studied enough this asset class.

By borrowing from it you can make your money work at two places at the same time, increasing your total return. It's a long term play as the front loaded fee takes a few years to recover from. But in essence it is not different than using a refi on a real estate property, except that you are protected on the downside as the cash value only goes up while real estate can go down. And on top of it, you have a life insurance to protect your family in case of early demise.

If it was so bad, why would so many sophisticated investors using them? You just need to find the right insurance agent specialized in this kind of policies as the run of the mill policy is definitely not what you want for that purpose.

 Borrowing against it, not from it ;)

That's how you can put your money to work in 2 places at one time.

Post: What does diversification look like to you!?

Thomas Rutkowski
#5 Personal Finance Contributor
Posted
  • Financial Advisor
  • Boynton Beach, FL
  • Posts 813
  • Votes 788
Quote from @V.G Jason:

This all depends on your income, your spending, and your dependents. This can go so many ways.

The last people you want to talk to is a normal, average financial advisor. And anyone that sells you life insurance. Kick their *** to the curb. 

 @Kegan Brenner

Leveraging the Cash Value of a Maximum Over-funded life insurance policy is a way to put your money to work in two places at one time. The naysayers don't know what they are talking about. You will make more money over time. It's not a get rich quick trick. It is a methodical approach to investing that allows you to earn a higher combined rate of return (Cash Value plus Real Estate)

Post: First Time Investment Property Strategy - San Diego

Thomas Rutkowski
#5 Personal Finance Contributor
Posted
  • Financial Advisor
  • Boynton Beach, FL
  • Posts 813
  • Votes 788

@Dan H.

If you are using 100% borrowed money for a deal, it's an infinite rate of return. You have NO money in the deal.

Post: First Time Investment Property Strategy - San Diego

Thomas Rutkowski
#5 Personal Finance Contributor
Posted
  • Financial Advisor
  • Boynton Beach, FL
  • Posts 813
  • Votes 788
Quote from @Dan H.:
Quote from @Thomas Rutkowski:
Quote from @Ari Lagunas:

Hi everyone,

I’m based in San Diego and looking to purchase my first investment property by March 2025. I earn around $15k/month from my business, but my income is somewhat variable, which might make securing financing challenging. I'm exploring different strategies and would appreciate your insights.

  • - What are your thoughts on using an FHA loan with a 3.5% down payment for a multifamily property?
  • - Is buying a foreclosure a viable strategy for me, and what should I be aware of?
  • - My family lives in Indiana. Would it make sense to buy my first investment property here in California, and to build the rest of my portfolio in Indiana? That way, the flights be considered a business expense?
  • - If I were to buy in Indiana, how should I go about finding a reliable property management agency?
  • - Would partnering with someone be advantageous in this situation?
  • - Should I purchase the property through an LLC for potential tax benefits?
  • - Do you think it's a good idea to start a whole life policy and use the cash value to fund the down payment?
  • - Are there alternative financing options, like private lenders or hard money loans, that could be suitable for someone with fluctuating income?
    - What tax credits or incentives might be available for first-time investors or those purchasing multifamily properties? How can I take full advantage of these?

I’m open to creative strategies and any other suggestions you might have. I'm just trying to think outside the box. Thanks in advance for your help!


Using the Whole Life Policy (or Indexed Universal Life) is very powerful. When you borrow from the insurance company, it is a loan against your Cash Value. That means you can earn an infinite rate of return because you'll be using 100% Financing. Your Cash Value remains in the Policy earning dividends and serving as collateral for the loan. Your money is literally working in 2 places at 1 time.

The Cash Value of a Maximum Over-funded Policy is also a great place to park your Cash while you are looking for a deal. Dividend and Interest Crediting rates are over 6% right now. What you lose in fees is quickly made up by the higher rate of growth. It's also important to realize that the fees are minimized in a Maximum Over-funded Policy. These are not typical life insurance policies.


If the down payment comes from an existing asset whether it is money from money market, money from savings account, money from CDs, money from heloc, money from selling stocks, money from stock margin, gift from family, money from life insurance it does not achieve a 100% LTV with respect to determining return. It is just a different source of the funds.

100% LTV implies no money from any other source. 

This is not to imply that life insurance is not a decent place to obtain the down.  Just recognize it is just another source of funds to use to meet the down payment of which there are many.


best wishes


 A life insurance policy loan is not your own asset. It is not a source of funds. The insurance company is loaning you THEIR money with your Cash Value as collateral. 

Post: First Time Investment Property Strategy - San Diego

Thomas Rutkowski
#5 Personal Finance Contributor
Posted
  • Financial Advisor
  • Boynton Beach, FL
  • Posts 813
  • Votes 788
Quote from @Ari Lagunas:

Hi everyone,

I’m based in San Diego and looking to purchase my first investment property by March 2025. I earn around $15k/month from my business, but my income is somewhat variable, which might make securing financing challenging. I'm exploring different strategies and would appreciate your insights.

  • - What are your thoughts on using an FHA loan with a 3.5% down payment for a multifamily property?
  • - Is buying a foreclosure a viable strategy for me, and what should I be aware of?
  • - My family lives in Indiana. Would it make sense to buy my first investment property here in California, and to build the rest of my portfolio in Indiana? That way, the flights be considered a business expense?
  • - If I were to buy in Indiana, how should I go about finding a reliable property management agency?
  • - Would partnering with someone be advantageous in this situation?
  • - Should I purchase the property through an LLC for potential tax benefits?
  • - Do you think it's a good idea to start a whole life policy and use the cash value to fund the down payment?
  • - Are there alternative financing options, like private lenders or hard money loans, that could be suitable for someone with fluctuating income?
    - What tax credits or incentives might be available for first-time investors or those purchasing multifamily properties? How can I take full advantage of these?

I’m open to creative strategies and any other suggestions you might have. I'm just trying to think outside the box. Thanks in advance for your help!


Using the Whole Life Policy (or Indexed Universal Life) is very powerful. When you borrow from the insurance company, it is a loan against your Cash Value. That means you can earn an infinite rate of return because you'll be using 100% Financing. Your Cash Value remains in the Policy earning dividends and serving as collateral for the loan. Your money is literally working in 2 places at 1 time.

The Cash Value of a Maximum Over-funded Policy is also a great place to park your Cash while you are looking for a deal. Dividend and Interest Crediting rates are over 6% right now. What you lose in fees is quickly made up by the higher rate of growth. It's also important to realize that the fees are minimized in a Maximum Over-funded Policy. These are not typical life insurance policies.

Post: What does diversification look like to you!?

Thomas Rutkowski
#5 Personal Finance Contributor
Posted
  • Financial Advisor
  • Boynton Beach, FL
  • Posts 813
  • Votes 788
Quote from @V.G Jason:
Quote from @Mike S.:
Quote from @V.G Jason:

 No, life insurance in all forms is an incredibly stupid vehicle to put money in. 

I strongly disagree with you. A properly structured cash value permanent life insurance can be an incredible tool in your wealth building strategy. You obviously have not studied enough this asset class.

By borrowing from it you can make your money work at two places at the same time, increasing your total return. It's a long term play as the front loaded fee takes a few years to recover from. But in essence it is not different than using a refi on a real estate property, except that you are protected on the downside as the cash value only goes up while real estate can go down. And on top of it, you have a life insurance to protect your family in case of early demise.

If it was so bad, why would so many sophisticated investors using them? You just need to find the right insurance agent specialized in this kind of policies as the run of the mill policy is definitely not what you want for that purpose.

 If you're paying your expense fees up front, it's going to be a terrible investment. I don't need to get into why, it should be obvious.

No sophisticated investor uses them. I don't know a soul in a real high net worth that has it, I see people maybe under $10,15 MM use them and think they're magic. Maybe $25MM net worth but they are new money and/or dumb money if not both that blindly follow an "advisor".  The real HNW don't touch this. 

Only people to fight me on this is the ones who sell them.


 Your money is literally working in two places at one time. Even though you take a haircut on the fees, you will accumulate more wealth over time. Would you rather have 85% of your money growing at 9% or 100% of your money growing at 6%? 

You're right. It's obvious.

Post: Need help finding a specific podcast episode

Thomas Rutkowski
#5 Personal Finance Contributor
Posted
  • Financial Advisor
  • Boynton Beach, FL
  • Posts 813
  • Votes 788
Quote from @Brett Synicky:

I remember this one.  Yes it was Josh and Brandon.  I forget the guys name.  Mormon guy from Utah I had looked him up after I heard the episode.   Since then however, I’ve learned that it’s best to keep life insurance and investments separate.  Term life insurance. I’m sure there are ways to make money with whole life or universal but the fees are outrageous and the payouts are not what they seem to be.  Btw I don’t claim to be an expert here I’ve just heard enough wealthy people talk about this.  


 Leveraging the Cash value of a Maximum over-funded policy enables a savvy investor to put their money to work in two places at one time. The combined growth of their assets will exceed that of simply investing only with their own money. 

Who cares what the fees are if you're making more money?

You can keep your investments separate, I'm using my resources a little smarter.

Post: Need help finding a specific podcast episode

Thomas Rutkowski
#5 Personal Finance Contributor
Posted
  • Financial Advisor
  • Boynton Beach, FL
  • Posts 813
  • Votes 788
Quote from @Nicole Heasley Beitenman:

There was an episode of the BP podcast YEARS ago where the investor was borrowing against life insurance to invest. It might have been back to the Brandon/Josh days. As they described it, the principal of the insurance earning interest wasn't diminished by the loan like, say, a 401k loan would be. So a $100k policy with a $50k loan against it still earned interest on the whole $100k, whereas a $100k 401k account with a $50k loan against it only earns interest on that remaining $50k until the loan is repaid. I tried searching for "life insurance," "life insurance loan," etc, but even after narrowing it to podcast results, I'm not finding the episode. Anyone else that's been listening as long as I have out there who can remember which episode I'm thinking of?


 That is exactly how Life Insurance works. That is what enables you to literally put your money to work in two places at one time.

If you can't find the podcast you are looking for, there is a ton of information in this old thread: https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/519/topics/245380-parad...

Policy design is everything. You want a Maximum Over-funded policy. When you look at the illustration, the 1st year Cash Value should be 85-90% of the Premium. If it's any less than that, there is too much Death Benefit. The high DB means higher fees and higher commissions.

Post: Exceptional Credit Score

Thomas Rutkowski
#5 Personal Finance Contributor
Posted
  • Financial Advisor
  • Boynton Beach, FL
  • Posts 813
  • Votes 788
Quote from @Sam Ghi:

Hi,

I am new to passive income, but I have exceptional credit score and I am considering infinite banking, without IUL, as it would take years to borrow over it. Instead, if I have 12-month CDs yielding 4.5% and I receive from a financial institution a personal loan collateralized by the CDs, with 4.5%+2% APR, and I invest in a low risk asset yielding 8%, I am receiving 6% annualized yield instead of 4.5%. If I pledge the low-risk asset for another collateralized personal loan with same or different lender at 7% and buy more of the low-risk, I add 1% to 6%. I may repeat some more times, I'm not doing a Ponzi scheme, while I am doing infinite banking, but through lenders. Am I missing anything? Is there a way to do infinite banking without third party lenders?



 


 Hey Sam,

It's not true that "it would take years to borrow over it". Whatever it is that you mean by "borrow over it", it will be true with Whole Life or IUL.

It's important to understand that under the Hood, Whole Life and IUL are virtually identical. The only place they differ is in how they credit the cash value. A Whole Life policy allocates the net gain on their reserves to each policy as a dividend. In an IUL, they take what would have been the dividend and use it to hedge Index Options. The goal is simply to earn a little higher return than they would by paying a dividend. Crediting will vary year to year, but should exceed Whole Life Dividends over time.

If someone tells you that "infinite banking" has to be done with Whole Life, they don't know what they are talking about. They're just repeating what someone told them. It's a system to sell more insurance.

A max-funded IUL and a max-funded whole life should look the same. You should be able to lay one illustration over another, if the premium, age and risk are the same. The amounts of death benefit and Cash value will be relatively equal notwithstanding some small company to company variations in costs.

The only difference between policies is the way they are designed. Are they designed for high cash value i.e. Maximum over-funded? Or are they designed for high death benefit?

Pick the policy type based on your comfort level with dividends vs variable interest crediting, policy flexibility, and loan options. 

Post: life insurance - need multiple brokers?

Thomas Rutkowski
#5 Personal Finance Contributor
Posted
  • Financial Advisor
  • Boynton Beach, FL
  • Posts 813
  • Votes 788

@Jacob Straussen

All agents are going to give you the same price for the same company. You'll want to make sure that you are looking at several different insurance companies. There are also a lot of great companies that don't put their products on those platforms, so there is something to be said for working with an agent rather than DIY. The prices are equal, and the service is free.