I agree with @Brent Coombs something looks about as kosher as pork chops at a bar mitzvah. My knee-jerk reaction was walk away, but now I'm thinking better of it. In this situation @Nick Stango you might consider doing the following:
- Contact the wholesaler you've been working with: tell him you're close to making a decision and would really like a contract. Please email it to you.
- Call or email the other wholesaler and tell him, "hey, I know the area well and I pass that house every so often please email me a contract. I'll have it back you you in a couple of days, I just have to run it by my wife..." Don't go see the place.
- While you're waiting for Yahoo 1 and 2 to get back to you look the homeowner up on public records.
If the home owner lives nearby GREAT! When you have a copy of both contracts (and email printouts of the emails they sent) go knock on the home owner's door at a reasonable hour. Introduce yourself and let them know that you were approached by someone trying to sell their house and you're interested in buying but you're suspicious that something isn't right about the situation. You don't want to get ripped of and can't "just walk away" without being sure THEY are not being ripped off by this guy. Ask them if they have 15 minutes to talk to "compare notes" about the situation.
If they don't live near by, then it's a different ball game you'll have to try this over the phone (much harder) and might get hung up on. IF they slam the door in your face because they're not listening to what you're actually saying--then you can walk away and not before.
If, however, they actually listen politely explain the situation:
- You had reason to be interested in 123 MAIN ST because you're an investor.
- Yahoo 1 appeared to have the property under contract... show them a copy of the contract and Yahoo 1's email.
- Then tell them you got suspicious when he didn't have keys to the place. I should note: it's probably unwise to admit you entered the property, even though you had a good faith belief the place was under contract and you had permission to enter... you may make the actual owner feel very violated and their response could be unpredictable and include things like police (if you're lucky) or buckshot (if you're not.)
- Tell them your suspicions grew when you noticed Yahoo 2 also had the property "listed" at a much higher price. Show them that contract and that email.
- Reiterate you don't want to get scammed and you'd be beside yourself if they got scammed and you found out about it later. See what they say.
They might in fact know these guys and be able to shed light on the situation, but they'll probably be confused as heck. Leave them a copy of the evidence and your card. If you get a call from the police and they ask to "interview" (interrogate) you tell them "Not without the presence of council [a lawyer.]" No matter what they say reply, "I'm sorry sir, given the gravity of the situation I can't make statements without the advice of counsel." Period. They have enough evidence with the printouts.
As for why you shouldn't talk to the police even though you're just bringing evidence of what is reasonably likely to be someone else's wrong doing, see:
It's really up to you if you want to go through all this trouble. But if you were in the home owner's shoes wouldn't you want to know? I sure as hell would.
PS: I'm not a lawyer. I just read books and watch YouTube videos. This isn't legal advice.