Originally posted by @Monica Morff:
Hi @James Fisher,
We did not have inspection when we purchased the property, but the buyers did. I have not seen their inspection report though. We did provide Seller's Disclosures and filled them out to the best of our knowledge with disclosing the water we did have, that we did not pull permits, etc. They are now saying that there are cracks in the foundation and we checked on disclosures that there were not, but we did not see them when we filled out disclosures.
No, we did not have anything like that. We had a plumber do all of the plumbing and my husbands dad is a contractor who helped with the work in the basement and no one raised concerns in the time they were working for us.
I am not an attorney, but will comment anyway. First off, assuming you're not an engineer in the area of basement flooding, I'm not sure how you should have known. You disclosed what you knew. I believe they're just hoping you're lying and afraid. Second, they got an inspection done. Their beef should be with their inspector. If he knew about a disclosed water issue, he should have and possibly did recommend they get an engineer involved. I've had this happen on several properties we've bought. That's part of the inspector's role.
There is always risk with purchasing real estate. It sounds to me like you acted in good faith. They're looking to get someone, anyone to pay for the risk they took that turned out badly for them.
THEY will have to pay a lot of money to an attorney to pursue this. I would do anything possible to make them accumulate for attorney's fees.
I actually had a situation similar to this- in reverse. We had some foundation work done. It was a disaster. We got a lawyer. Both parties postured. We decided it wasn't worth the risk, dropped it and moved on.
This is an interesting situation. I hope you keep us all posted. Best of luck to you!