Just finished going through the whole thread. Phew!
Summary of my learning:
1)
@Tyler Jahnke , @Andrew Buchanan have had some problems regarding communications, but otherwise, things are working out fine.
2) @Jay Hinrichs He is a true legend of BP, with experience in all aspects unlike anyone else here. He has nothing personal against Clayton. Rather, he is questioning the WHOLE model of going after cash flow in low income neighborhoods. Many people agree with him. Most experienced players are with him (@Diane G.), and has their own personal gains with appreciation play to show for it.
3) I had a call with James yesterday. They are not hiding anything. The neighborhoods are solid C , appreciation may never happen. But They truly believe this model will work out. James works from near where I live. Letting people work from home is in line with their philosophy of "freedom" (I like that)
4) My take: a)Things are working out for both Clayton and the customers
b) But .. 2/3 .. or even 10 years is too early to tell. Demographic trends, economy, jobs, automation, robot cars.. I have done a whole lot of research, seen reports using machine learning, GIS etc. Indy's phenomenal population growth has stalled.
c) I would personally go for $950+ rent range in a state/city with solid population/ economic growth. (Jacksonville, FL ? or Forth Work, TX, or San antonio, TX ? ) Exit strategy, and some appreciation potential is important to me. I would use the peace of mind + turnkey experience to work on some bigger and better deals.