It's hard to loose a good tenant, but I think it's worst to keep on loosing cash.
You're currently unsure if you can get such a good tenant, well you can. I would set rent price at $1800 (or whatever is the top of the market is ... check out rentometer.com) if your place is as good as you say and not many of those are available you will get what you are asking for. People who can pay top of the market are usually the ones who care to live in a clean and nice space, they will take care of your house.
Do your due diligence, screen them through background check and credit report (check out https://cozy.co/for-landlords/tenant-screening). Have them pay for the screening (that on it's own scares a lot of people who know they have no chance of qualifying). Set the deposit at twice the monthly rent (tenant needs to know that they will loose that cash if they will not take care of your property).
The first time around it seems like you were pretty lucky to get a good tenant. Well the second time around you should not use your luck as much.