I'm on the tail end of a 24-unit BRRRR and I have a lot of vacant units to fill, most of them already renovated. Solidly C area. I've had a rental listing up on that property very consistently for the past few months and I'm seeing a general uptick in inquiries since the shelter-in-place order went into effect on March 24th. I think there are three factors at play here:
1) Many renters have decided to put off their move until after the pandemic has passed (they inquire, I follow up, they've decided to wait). While that's is taking people out of the prospective tenant pool...
2) A boatload of people, primarily in their 20s, have decided that their current living situation is untenable in a quarantine situation (not to mention it just got extended for another month). My property is in a C area, the situation will be different in better and worse neighborhoods, but I'm seeing a lot of people who need to get away from a roommate/flatmate or who've decided to live with their parents while working full-time to save money, until now. This has increased demand for my renovated C-class 1-beds with relatively high rents, even factoring for the people taking themselves out of the market for now.
3) With Ohio being a more proactive state in responding to the health crisis, frankly we haven't felt much of the impact of COVID-19 in Cincinnati (Hamilton County) yet and people aren't taking the quarantine as seriously as people in other parts of the state, much less the country.
I'm grateful to be considered an essential business (Realtor/property management), but right now it feels like the vast majority of Cincinnatians are taking every excuse to continue with business-as-usual.