@Soren Nelson, thanks for the response! My hope in asking the question was to spur on the good conversation by way of using a live listing that is getting a lot of attention. Over the course of the weekend, we had 50 showings and a multitude of offers. I will wait to comment on exactly how competitive it got until we have a mutually accepted offer, but regardless I am not sure how some investors are making homes like this pencil when spending so much upfront acquiring the property. One thought is they are rehabbing and holding it as a rental.
You're completely correct about the basement being a large variable on this one. Given the floor plan and ability for it to be a 4 bed/2bath, I think the ARV on this could be mid 200's if done right, however, that is going to take a significant investment of 45-55k to rehab, so there may not be a ton of meat on the bone.
I really appreciate you chiming in and will follow back up soon!
Sidenote: I would consider this neighborhood "east-central/upriver"