@Heather Lanser
Hi Heather, not a bad position to be in!
With the current market conditions, I would advise against taking on an additional SFH or a small multifamily property. The cash income will be too small relative to your investment and you will be ask risk of a downturn devaluing your total investment. As an example, if you bought another SFH at the numbers you described as market - $300k, $1300 rent. That would require a 25% down payment plus closing costs totaling an~$80k initial investment. If you yielded 45% of the rent after all expenses, that would equate to a 8.5% return not including the extra work and the risk of losing equity with the downturn.
Alternatively, middle market syndicates are in a much more stable section of the market. Properties valued between $2M-$50M are usually sold on a cap rate basis, meaning that the income drives the price of the property, not local comps or speculation. Deals in this market yield 16-18% total IRR and 8%+ tax mitigated yearly cash flow.
If interested, reach out, my team syndicates deals for people in precisely in your situation looking to find long term stability. I hope this was helpful.
Best,
Salem