I wanted to update this thread to explain how things turned out.
Let me start at the beginning. I bought the property in October of 2020 for $109k. I financed it with no money down using my securities-backed line of credit. Since this was during COVID, I was able to lock in a seven-year fixed interest rate at 2.48%, interest only. The monthly interest payment is $220.
The tenant in place at the time rarely paid her rent of $900 / mo and was destroying the property.
When the drunk driver drove into the property in Sept. 2021, the tenant moved out. Someone stole all of the electrical wiring and plumbing in the property and I'm strongly suspicious it was her. I know for a fact that she stole the refrigerator.
Anyways, it cost about $107k to rehab and pay the carrying costs of the property. I received a little bit more than that from the insurance, after paying my public adjuster. It was a great suggestion that I hire a public adjuster. I was pretty lucky to pick a good contractor who did a really good job, unsupervised while I live in Nevada and the property is in Missouri. They even put in some upgrades that were within the budget.
The property took about six months to renovate and I now have a reliable tenant in there. The rent is $325 / mo higher than it was before. Property is now worth about $150k-155k.
Major lessons learned:
1) Sometimes the biggest disasters lead to the biggest upside.
2) I filed two insurance claims here - one for the property damage and one for the theft of electrical & plumbing. I probably should not have filed the theft claim. Filing too many claims leads to your insurance rates going up overall. Now, I'm seeing the premiums going up on most of my rentals. The theft claim was only worth $9,500 and that's an amount I could have paid out of pocket and still made good returns on this investment.
3) I spent a good amount of time dealing with the contractor handling issues that came up. On my rehabs out-of-state, I usually have an independent project manager handling these issues. I should have done that here. It is not my strength to make good design choices and it was difficult to make decisions on design choices. Also hard to keep track of the progress of a project from out of state.