@Sylvia B. - Well things have not worked themselves out as of yet.
Since originally posting this topic I had a chance to meet with the owner of the 2 houses and found out I did not have all accurate information. He was willing to sell 3 houses as follows:
- 3 br 1ba - asking $20k firm - rents for $425/mo
- 3 br 1 1/2ba - asking $20k firm - rents for $450/mo
- 3 br 1 1/2ba - asking $30k firm - rents for $525/mo (Higher price because it is in a different town with higher property values)
So as you can see, the cashflow is not what I thought it would be.
So I made and offer on the $40,000 TH that I mentioned with no HOA. @Michael Siekerka made some valid points about the HOA not being a reason to be afraid, but I think the one thing I forgot to mention was that the parking lot is in very bad shape with several large potholes. This will not be maintained by he city and if there are a bunch of uncooperative owners we will be in big trouble when the parking lot becomes unnavigable, which will be soon. I have concern that with a parking lot that bad prospective future tenants will not want to live there if it means tearing up their cars!
So, I offered them $32k and they countered at full price. So since they did not want to negotiate AT ALL, I felt that was a sign that I needed to follow my heart and stay away from the dilapidated parking lot. However, I would have loved to own in that community and hopefully had a chance to pick up other properties their eventually. Mainly because I liked the location and lay-out of the houses.
The other 3 properties are still available because he is not actively seeking to sell them. He is giving the opportunity to buy to a few select people.
@Randy Duncan take a look at this also. Does it still make since with the reduced rents?