Quote from @Jeffrey McKee:
Quote from @Richard Rohrbough:
Hello BP friends. I need your help on what to do with my rental.
My monthly mortgage payment is greater than the rent I can get by $150 and the 2023 taxes are going up another $150/month.
I’m sure this is a common issue, so what are my options beyond the three I can think of below? Anything creative?
1. Ignore it/deal with it/subsidize it with other properties until someday rent catches up with my payment (meanwhile equity should have grown).
2. Make a large payment against the mortgage and ask the mortgage company to re-amortize the loan so that my monthly payment is less than what I can get for rent.
3. Sell the house (and make a better purchase on the next property).
A couple of questions first. How long have you owned the property? What was your reason for buying the property in the first place and what was your original exit strategy? Can you sell for a profit today? What city and state is the property in? Is the long-term appreciation worth eating the monthly cost of holding? Will it value your business to have this loss as a write-off? Are there better places for you to put your capital?
Good questions, Jeff. Thanks for sending them my way.
I bought the property a year ago (June 2022), rehabbed it over the summer and then tried to sell it in the fall. The market had dropped significantly such that I would have lost money on the house, so I decided to rent it out instead. Even at a loss each month, I felt it gave me a chance to someday get back to even or more whereas selling would be an immediate for sure loss!
My reason for purchasing was to fix & flip to gain cash, not cash-flow. After doing a few f&f properties and building up my cash, I then planned to shift to focusing on cash flow. So, I likely will continue with my plan of f&f to build up cash (plus keep this one property that isn't cash-flowing), but try to do a better job of buying right.
I can't sell for a profit today, but it would allow me to pay off the mortgage and have about $50k in cash to deploy again.
The property is in San Antonio. As for long-term appreciation, it's possible, maybe even probable. It's in a downtown neighborhood that is regentrifying, so I think there will continue to be interest in homes in this area which should help with appreciation over time.
There's some short-term benefit to writing this off, but there's probably a larger long-term benefit to keeping it if it appreciates and cashflows someday.
I don't have a specific property in mind that would be a better place for the cash, but I do believe that I've learned a lot over the last year and that I can use that education to make better purchases going forward. However, I don't have to sell this one property to make better decisions on the next property. I can keep this one property that isn't cash-flowing AND make better decisions on the next property. As my portfolio grows, I'll be less concerned about this one property AND I'll be giving the property a chance to get back to even or more.