Originally posted by @Collette Freitas:
so what im hearing everyone saying, that because my dog broke only 2 pickets, and she had the 2 pickets replaced, I have to pay her the $100 that she paid to have the entire fence installed. So my neighbor gets a free fence because my dog broke 2 pickets??? To me that just doesn't seem fair. Like I have said over and over and over..... I have no problems paying for damages that he has done, but I have a problem with someone charging me for things he didn't do but now she has a new fence. She had her discounted handyman put up an entire fence between her and another neighbor and charged her $100 for the entire project. And because he didn't charge her anything to replace 2 pickets and put up an extra board, that I should pay her fence installation. And then lock my dog up in a box and problem will be solved.
First and foremost, life is not fair. YOUR dog, damaged someone's property. And to be honest, if $100 is all they are asking for to be made whole you're being let off easy. And there is no way their entire fence was only $100 to replace unless it is only a 2 picket fence.
You keep complaining about a $100 bill from the neighbor. Most professional handymen and contractors will have a minimum fee. Mine is $250, while I don't always charge it, I can.
You are getting off lite at $100.
A reasonable argument could be made for you to replace their entire fence. I'd imagine the area fixed is different than the rest of the fence and an eyesore. To truly be made whole they might argue that their entire fence needs to be replaced since, the mismatched fence is both an eyesore and could be affecting their home value.
Put down your shovel and stop digging.