My question is this, if it’s rented for $995 now, why not just put the 20% down and keep it. Leave it alone, get a heloc on the property so you can still access the cash if needed for the “speed bumps” what’s wrong with leaving money in a deal for a safety net? Brrrr isn’t the only way to invest. Cashflow would look a lot better with 20% down. Refinance it after first turn and Reno it then
The deals I have been offering on give me back 5-10k and give me $150-$250 per door after allowing 28% for expenses plus PITI while capturing 25-30k in equity. Several folks have warned me about these numbers also. I feel like they're borderline deals. But it's whats in my backyard. I'd rather see them before I invest out of town. I have passed on deals that don't give me at least $150/door numerous times while searching. $150/dr is my minimum number while pulling all my money back out. But I also want a significant amount of equity to go along with it. My vote is bail if this is the only way to structure the deal.
Keep in mind I Am new to buy and hold. I have flipped a couple houses and have a good reserve account built up before I even considered doing this. I wouldn’t recommend doing anything until you have good money set aside for s**t hitting the fan.