Hi Prab -
I own a handful of properties in Indy along with a partner. So far we have kept the properties in our names but are starting to strategize about getting things under the LLC.
We do have an umbrella policy as an extra layer of protection, though. We've done all our insurance through Carl Savich of General Insurance Services. Can't recommend working with him and that agency enough! They've been fantastic and we have gotten other quotes along the way and always found Carl to be right there competitive on price but find it's so much easier to have a great agent to be more responsive and provide expertise rather than go through Geico online or something.
As for a lender, my most recent purchase (just last month) was financed through Busey Bank and the LO is Casey Wilson. And she is awesome!! Seriously, I got rejected by almost 10 other lenders but she knows her stuff and was able to get it done. That was able to be conventional but they have a ton of products that they finance and hold so no need to meet fannie/freddie guidelines. I ended up closing at a crazy low rate and low closing costs. Honestly you have to call her.
The posting won't let me share contact info but I have PM'd you. For others reading, I'm sure you can google search or visit the companies websites, or PM me.
Good luck to you!