Someone said the following:
"For the rebuttal:
1. bring comps that are within the last 90 days - do they exist? dont you think if they existed the appraiser would use them?
2. bring comps that are within about 250sf living space as yours...it's not all about square feet unless this is your first deal or you're a real estate agent and dont know any better..
3. see what they gave on price for them and see if they discounted or increased the value on that those...that made no sense :)
4. add anything that you have permitted, get permits from the city to add or any other supporting documents. that wont matter.
For rebuttal and prior to the inspection by the appraiser:
1. bring the Apprasier "your" comps, this guy/girl maybe from an hour outside the city and no idea what parts of the area would fit best. Appraisers toss that junk in the trash. dont waste your time you're proviing to the appraiser you, the agent, dont know how to bracket.
2. bring a list (spreadsheet) of all the upgrades and anything else that was done to the house with a dollar figure, they attach that to their report to justify price. Spending $1000 on something is not necessarily going to get you $1000 back. It also sets you up for significant disappointment. Definitely the "best" advice here but not worth what you think
3. add documents for permits as mention. dont bother. waste of time.