I don't think that the seller's agent has a leg to stand on....although you may have been approved based on your w-2 income, if you were using any rental income to qualify for the loan, then your 1040's will come into the equation, and if you have a lot of deductions, then that will reduce your income and may have been enough to kick you out of the parameters of the loan guidelines. This is always an unknown until your mortgage loan officer has all of your income documentation, although, if he/she was using any rental income to qualify you, they should've known that they would need the 1040's to verify income. You should most certainly still be able to obtain a mortgage for the property though, you could go with a stated income loan, no doc loan, no ratio loan, lite doc, or go through a "non-prime" mortgage provider. I will advise you that the rate will be a little higher on these types of loans, but if you really want the property, you should still have the means to do it. I don't believe that you were trying to mislead anyone about your intentions or ability to get a mortgage. Tell the sellers agent to extend the contract and get off of your back while you adjust your plan. Good luck!!!
David Spencer
Mortgage Consultant
570-412-4438