@Jose Contreras
This is quite the informational post, thank you for your question Jose! I will be a physician in 5 years (just beginning residency) and am brand new to the REI world, so this question is important for me down the road. I have a similar question, although tailored to my specific situation, and I hope it may help answer your question through a different perspective:
It appears that, as a high income earner (>150k), it is nearly impossible to deduct rental income and expenses without REP status until the accumulated passive losses can be used to offset the home sale. However, if you and your spouse are unable to/unwilling to commit to REP status, is there a way to mitigate the increased tax burden prior to that home sale?
For example, if the homes are owned through an entity like an LLC, the QBI deduction can allow you to pass through 20% of your business income (if your taxable income is below a certain threshold). This changes if your taxable income is above that threshold (details here: www.fool.com/the-blueprint/amp/qualified-business-income-deduction/).
Could this same principle apply to a partnership with an individual with REP status? Can ownership belong to that individual in an LLC/partnership/S-Corp/C-Corp and have the non-REP individual receive compensation through non-taxable means such as employer IRA matching contributions or gifts?