Hey Jacob,
Congrats on building equity in both properties—it sounds like you're in a great position to leverage your assets for future investments!
Using a HELOC on Property A to fund a rental in the $150-200K range could work well if you're focused on steady cash flow. Just ensure that the projected rental income comfortably covers the new payments, including the HELOC. In my experience, cash flow is key, especially for long-term holds, so running a detailed DSCR (Debt Service Coverage Ratio) analysis might be a good step here.
On the flip side, if you're eyeing faster returns, a flip might be more lucrative. Since you’ve already done renovations, you probably know how to manage rehab timelines and budgets. Just be sure to account for holding costs, which can add up quickly.
Another option—since you're well-positioned in Austin—could be bridge financing or hard money lending for your flip. This way, you'd preserve more of your HELOC for future deals or emergencies.
Feel free to reach out if you'd like to discuss DSCR options, or if you're thinking about hard money for any upcoming projects. I specialize in both and would be happy to help you crunch the numbers!
Best of luck with your next move!