My first SFH was in Jacksonville and was purchased via Roofstock. The property was my first out of state investment, and it taught me everything I know. Since then, I have purchased mostly higher CoC units, and multifamily units. While the property performs well, I am in a sort of dilemma (sell or keep) on what do with it since I am shifting focus to MFH going forward. Details below:
- Purchased Nov. 2016 on Roofstock for $90,000
- Loan was at 20% down at 4.375% (great rate!). Current loan amount is $69,146
- Rented at $993 on a 2 year lease ending in Dec 2019
- Upgraded the roof in Jan 2019 (cost $8,000)
- Cash flow after all PITI, reserves (20%), vacancy (5%), prop management (10%) is $171/mo
Here is where I am having trouble with and mistakes I made with this:
- My entire 2 year cashflow and reserves are gone based on an $8,000 roof repair. Back to square one.
- Lease will end in winter month (i.e., Dec 2019 to Jan 2020). Tenant has been in place for 3 years now. They have not stated their intent to leave (too early now)
- If tenant leaves, I am left with a vacant property in the winter months and may be difficult to get it rented
- Expecting to spend at least $1,000 on turnover it tenant leaves. I do yearly inspections so I know property is in overall good shape but of course, basic wear & tear will happen
What should I do?
- Sell? With realtor fees, and slight appreciation from $90,000 to maybe $100,000 price point, I will not be able to recoup my roof repair costs. I will be able to get back my downpayment though to reinvest into my next MFH.
- Hold on to it? That comes with the risks and extra costs I've outlined above
While this is not an underperforming property (mostly it was me underperforming while I was learning the past 2 years of the ins and outs), I am shifting focus to MFH and thus I do not see this property long term in my portfolio (unless I am convinced otherwise). I am not hard-pressed for funds nor do I live off any cashflow from my properties.
What would you do? Thanks for the help!