@Ben Rishwain That's true in the case of a traditional office building, especially one that has only a handful of units. But for these small, "executive office suites", there's not typically any moving of walls or any build-out at all. In rare cases where a tenant needs that, they would bear the cost.
It still may be the case that that MF carries less risk than office buildings, but a building with a large number of small executive office units would logically be less risky than traditional office space.
Also, I initially presented an oversimplified scenario just to compare the different property types. But here are more details of the actual properties I'm considering:
The office opportunity is a single building with 15 units, each about 600 sq ft, fully rented. The MF opportunity is actually two 6-plexes, about half-rented. (Half of the units need paint, carpet, etc. to be rent-ready.) The purchase price and cap rate are nearly the same for the one office building and the two 6-plexes. (Well, it would be once the 6-plexes are fully rented.)
Also consider what you have to maintain for each property:
Office: 1 Roof
6-plexes: 2 Roofs
Office: 4 HVAC units
6-plexes: 12 furnaces + 12 AC window units
Office: 2 kitchenettes (Fridge, sink)
6-plexes: 12 full kitchens (Above, plus range/oven, vent/hood, dishwasher, etc.)
Office: 4 bathrooms
6-plexes: 12 bathrooms
A couple more confounding factors: The office building is built in 2005 and located in a suburb of a major metropolitan area currently experiencing substantial growth. Whereas the 6-plexes are built in 1969 and located in a mid-sized midwestern city with a stable market, but not much growth. I would think the office building might appreciate more, but of course, I won't count on it.
Considering all that, would you still favor MF?
@Jeff Kehl Yeah, I'm familiar with Wework and similar co-working concepts. Executive suites are a mid-point between traditional offices and co-working spaces. I have thought that, if the market demands it, I could offer some co-working options with this building. However, I think that would be more management intensive, and currently this executive suite concept seems to have a strong niche in this metro area.