Originally posted by @Rich Somers:
This is definitely not true - I'm curious what leads you to make this statement? What are the rents you are projecting when completed?
One problem you will run into if doing a $70K cosmetic renovation on a 5-plex in Old Louisville is that tenants who are attracted to the area and are willing to pay top dollar want the following:
-Original historic charm (No covering up original wood floors, trim, etc)
-Central heat and air (their own system, not shared)
-Newer electric
-Laundry and off-street parking
If this happens to be the 5-plex on Ormsby, you may want to do some more digging on whether it is actually a 5-plex and if the basement unit can be legally used as an apartment or not. PVA has it listed as a boarding house. We renovated a property like this several years ago and were forced to turn it back into a SFR due to zoning restrictions.
From experience renovating several of these properties, I can tell you that $70K will not go very far on something like this if you're expecting to be at the very top end of the market when finished.
Happy to provide additional feedback and/or answer questions if you have any!