Quote from @John Warren:
@Michael Mahung there is a lot of info we would need to help, but if this is in a good area then I would go for it. Normally a 4 unit will bring in more like $4500 per month in most Chicago neighborhoods once it is stabilized (assuming some 2 bed units and a garage). This means you can eventually refinance out of that FHA loan down the line which will make this thing a very strong cash flow property.
Your vacancy is likely a bit high based on most areas of Chicago. We run 5% internally, and on a 4 unit you might even just put down 1 unit's rent for the year (as that is likely the most you see in most years).
Management is maybe something you don't need to run if you are living in the property. I know incoming are a bunch of sophisticated investors who will tell you to always run management, but if you are putting down 3.5% and living in the property, do you really think you are going to pay a manager? The answer is probably not!
Like others have said, my big concern is whether you will even be able to use the FHA loan. This is missed a lot here in the forums, but sellers (and listing agents) hate FHA deals since they have a higher failure rate in terms of contracts falling apart. If you can get a quality 4 unit with an FHA loan that cash flows, do it.
Thanks for the tip about vacancy, I've tried reaching out to several PM's about vacancy in different neighborhoods and have had trouble opening discussion.
I agree with your point about management, but my long term goal would be to hire a good property manager so I can have some peace of mind while I scale up so I like to run it with that in mind.
I ended up passing on this property due to finding many more issues/repairs during the open house. Additionally, we were not allowed to see one of the units despite giving 48 hour notice.
Really appreciate your input!