@Chris Eaker @John G. Thank you!
@Brendon Grover The NY market is extremely cost prohibitive right now, it's nearly impossible to cash flow with debt service in place. I own a co-op as my primary residence and have toyed with the idea of house hacking but I really like where I live and would have to move to a little rough area to make the numbers work, which I decided against.
There are cheaper markets here in NY (upstate) but I just don't see the potential and growth that a metropolitan area (like Philadelphia) has to offer. The area I invested in is no Fishtown or Northern Liberties but it's literally blocks from University City's expansion so it's only a matter of time. The appreciation aspect is nice and all but I made this decision based on the fact that it will cash flow above all else.
Looking at the appraisal, it appears that there may be an opportunity to add value as some of the comps were adjusted downward. I will perform further due diligence to reaffirm those findings and explore the idea of pulling my cash back out if I can find more than the 2 renovated comps that sold for 85k.
Long story short, if I would have waited until I could pull the trigger in my own market I would have been waiting forever. Expanding my horizon a bit I was able to start now.