Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Matthew McNeil

Matthew McNeil has started 31 posts and replied 686 times.

Post: Capital gains when transferring rental into my LLC

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 741

Nope. And, just for clarity; you don't "sell" your rentals to your LLC. You transfer them using a Quitclaim.

Post: Paying a larger % downpayment up front

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Mark Dolan:

Hi guys, I am new to the site and I am exploring the possibilities of investing in a rental property over the coming year. My biggest concern however is that I may struggle to get approved of a mortgage based on my low income reflected over the past few years. I am wondering if lenders allow you to pay a larger down payment to minimize the amount that you would need to borrow. I figure if people can buy houses with cash they perhaps they allow for something like this. Sorry if this is a silly question, I am still totally new to this and trying to figure out the basics. 

Thanks!!

The way you've described your post, you're implying a direct connection between qualifying for a loan and the size of the down payment. There's obviously more involved to qualify for a loan.  If, however, you want to help qualify yourself to a lender who's not quite convinced to approve your application, then "yes" you can put more money down. Then, you can do a cash-out refi later and reinvest it into another property.

Post: When do you say you aren't a newbie anymore?

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 741

Since you offered your post as "light hearted," I'd have to say it was the first time I wasn't nervous at Closing wondering if I'd made a mistake with my numbers, and feeling comfortable that I could sign documents without asking for clarity on every page the Title officer was sliding in front of me.  That was my 5th time. 

Post: Need a CPA for Foreign Earned Income and who deals with K-1

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 741

My CPA prepares my taxes using the FEIE because I legally reside out of country.  As @Eamonn McElroy wrote above, you should be able to find a CPA here on BP.
Word of advice for what its worth.  The only problem I've had filing a FEIE is that lenders are not generally familiar with it when they look over your tax returns in consideration of a new loan application.  Be prepared to try and explain it to a lender who has no idea what you're talking about. They understand you're living overseas. What trips them up is seeing the $105,900 deduction for 2019 on the tax return.   



Post: One LLC per Rental Property? How to Manage Them Efficiently?

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Kerry Baird:

@Matthew McNeil, I’m curious about your last portion above...what is often omitted? 

No blending of personal funds with the LLC. Separate bank account. Insurance policy must be in name of LLC. Asset needs to be QC'd into LLC. If PM is used, the Management Agreement needs to be in name of PM. No money can be given to LLC unless it clarified as a loan. Signing checks must include the identification by signatory as "Managing Member", etc.

Post: Simply put, I don't know what the heck I'm doing

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Byron Villela Jr.:

Hello all,

Just thought to say as someone who doesn't quite have direction and idea of what I'm doing, I'm thankful to have been introduced to the bigger pockets podcast and community. I believe my subscription to this platform is an attempt to enter the realm of possibilities that real estate has to offer. At this point, I'm just ensuring that I fix my relationship with money and as a result, I have been working diligently at saving money and upping my credit score.

I intend to invest, become an owner of land/property and build wealth for generations to follow; This is my mission statement. I look forward to associating with likeminded people and soaking up the loads of knowledge you all possess.

Greatly appreciate you,
Byron V.

Byron, every BP member who lands on your post is smiling because each of us can relate.  Welcome to BP.  This is a community of people willing to help each other move forward and become successful.  You are surrounded by friends!

Post: One LLC per Rental Property? How to Manage Them Efficiently?

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Robert Carlson:

@Matthew McNeil, thanks for the post and question. A few books I read in the Rich Dad series highly recommended structuring real estate investments under separate LLCs to limit liability, and that's why I am thinking about it. I have one rental property under my own name, and I do have a $1M umbrella liability policy on that rental unit, but my insurance company states in the policy that it is void if I rent for less than 6 months at a time. However, not even sure if $1M is enough if I short term rent and someone slips, falls, dies, and then family sues? Could not liability potentially go over that amount? If yes, would that not then put all my personal family assets at risk? I am sure nothing is risk free, but then wondering why so many books I've been reading have suggested it. Plus, if I own all my properties in one LLC, one terrible thing happening in one of them could subject all my other income to any rulings against me in a theoretical big lawsuit.

Thanks again for the post!

The premise of your question is the concern that a liability claim might exceed $1M. I asked this exact question of my attorney who specializes in RE. His response was that such a lawsuit is extremely unlikely and rare. However, it’s important to position ourselves from a worse case scenario and work backwards to make sure we’re fully protected based on our level of comfort regarding risk.

And, "yes" if a worst-case scenario did happen then an aggressive attorney would most likely go after your personal assets, which further supports your desire to put the asset into an LLC.

The books you’re referring to are for the most part not necessarily referring to the scenario you’re describing. Rather, they’re laying out a framework for asset protection and not the alleviation of a worst-case scenario lawsuit.

Each asset in my portfolio is held in a separate LLC. If you decided to go the LLC route its important that you understand all involved in making sure you don't pierce the veil, which most people inadvertently end up doing by omission. You need to do your research. Start by asking the Title company if the insurance is forfeited if you transfer the asset. Then contact your lender to make sure you don't violate the due-on-transfer clause.

Post: One LLC per Rental Property? How to Manage Them Efficiently?

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 741

What is your LTV per property? If its high and you carry $1M insurance per property then why do you need an LLC?

Post: At what point do you take your PM behind the barn?

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @James Wise:
Originally posted by @Matthew McNeil:

I've been patient and given my PM the benefit of the doubt.  Everything went good for several years when they managed a couple hundred properties.  Unfortunately, things are different now and I feel like another number in their tech App once they hit 500 doors under their management.  I'm ready to pivot to another PM.  It seems that PMs get to a place of critical mass where they're trying to manage too many properties, but they've lost the personal touch.  My fear is I'll pivot to another PM then discover a few years later that I'm in the same place.

You get a lot of folks that equate personal service with better service. In reality not really the case. Just gives the owner the feels. Doesn't pencil out as an effective way to manage the property though. Property Management doesn't even break even till the company hits 200+ doors. So yea I'd say that you'd run a good shot at ending up in the same place a few years from now if you left and went to another growing property management company. Or worse, went to one that was so bad they couldn't scale up to a profitable amount. 

Thanks for the feedback James.  I've done my best to balance out OR equate personal service with better service, which is why I've given my PM the benefit of the doubt.  I don't need the personal touch as long as I'm confident they're doing their job.  In my case, my PM spent $1100 to replace a H2O tank on one of my SFHs without consulting me, and I've not seen a statement on another property since August. And, they messed up the deposit on a 3rd property. The difficulty has been that I value relationship.  However that value can't be maintained at the expense of what its costing me.  Time to pull the trigger. 

Post: At what point do you take your PM behind the barn?

Matthew McNeilPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Boise/Portland
  • Posts 709
  • Votes 741
Originally posted by @Patricia Steiner:

Before it comes to asking this question.  I recently replaced several of my resource partners after tolerating their "expectation" of my business versus appreciating it.  The change was immediate.  I wish I had done it much earlier.  I was loyal to a fault.  And, all those reasons for holding off doing so - "it'll be a hassle/disruptive/more money" - were unfounded.

Some relationships were never meant to be forever; it's the natural evolution of business.  Go ahead and make the change - and stop rewarding your current PMs poor performance with your business.

Well said Patricia.  The relationship I've enjoyed with my PM for over a decade seems to have come to the end of a season.  Its unfortunate.  I just need to pull the trigger and let them go.  Thanks!