Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Matt Calnan

Matt Calnan has started 3 posts and replied 24 times.

Post: New investors alert

Matt CalnanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Lethbridge, Alberta
  • Posts 26
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Chris Kendrick:
Quote from @Dan H.:
Quote from @Chris Kendrick:

Ok so for first time new investors, i went to multiple of banks and there is no such thing as no money down or 3 or 5 percent low down payments, its normal 20 or 25 percent down, so only way i see to profit from rental or investment properties is either flip or do the brrrr method , cause you cant put a down payment of 20k,30k or 40 or 50k, cause it will take you forever to get that money back if your only cash flowing around $300 or $400 a month, you cant buy a property every 7 or 10 years doing the conventional method of buying a house, so you almost got to rehab the house and either flip or get it appraised for more and cash refi to get your money back and rent it out, i dont know how everyone making money, please dont say seller finace, cause that dont exist

 Seems like you are telling us there is no way.  Give up.  Do not ask questions and educate.  It’s impossible.  RE is not for you.  

RE has many different strategies.  Seller financing does not exist?  I guess that is one less property that I own.  Buy direct from seller, 4 less properties.  Good brrrr/value add, 8 less.  

As has already been stated owner occupied is an easy way to enter with minimal down. Naca is full of hurdles and has a learning curve. Have you looked into it. How about traditional FHA? High LTV combined with house hacking including by room, STE/mtr, or traditional LTR.

Non-owner occupied there are value adds, BRRRR, Partnering, arbitrage to name a few. Any of which could result in none of your investment being trapped in the investment. Same rent options as house hacking.

This really is just the Beginning of RE strategies as I concentrated on one that does not commit significant funds long. 

There are numerous passive options that trap funds but have produced great returns: syndication, mineral rights (We timed our acquisition perfect and had ~40% return on investment on year 1), NNN, Notes, REITS, etc.

You need to educate on possibilities rather than it is not possible (pessimism is not your ally.  It is possible.  Many people on this site are proof it is possible.  

Good luck

Hard to get seller financing,  i ask 2 realtors about that and they laughed and said your not going to find any one to do that, brrrr is the really only strategy i see, hear alot of haters saying oh there are tons of ways, but i dont see any body throwing numbers out there for examples

 Throwing around numbers for examples? This is a quote from me above:

"I have 3 multifamily deals on the go right now, all of which are seller-financed for the entire down payment. It's 560 doors in total."

Don't think that realtors are going to understand seller financing. What everyone is trying to say, is that you can't just base your beliefs on what a couple of people say. These things work. A lot of people get seller financing. A lot of people only do deals when they get seller financing. But that doesn't mean that it should happen on their first attempt. The first deal might have taken 100 offers. 1000 offer. Who knows. Someone else said above, it's about relationships. You have to find the right person, then build the relationship with them. 

Post: STR without TVs ???

Matt CalnanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Lethbridge, Alberta
  • Posts 26
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Joe S.:
Quote from @David Ramirez:

I think you would get bad reviews if you don't offer at least one TV. 


 What if I  made it clear in the description so that a person knew up front prior to booking?


People aren't going to pick that out in the description. And I think it would turn a lot of people away by having that in the description. I wouldn't normally use a TV in a vacation property, but I would think it was crazy to not have them available. And I would also stay away from having them "available upon request". That might be even weirder than just not having TVs in the first place haha!

Post: New investors alert

Matt CalnanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Lethbridge, Alberta
  • Posts 26
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Dan H.:
Quote from @Matt Calnan:
Quote from @Chris Kendrick:
Quote from @Dan H.:
Quote from @Chris Kendrick:

Ok so for first time new investors, i went to multiple of banks and there is no such thing as no money down or 3 or 5 percent low down payments, its normal 20 or 25 percent down, so only way i see to profit from rental or investment properties is either flip or do the brrrr method , cause you cant put a down payment of 20k,30k or 40 or 50k, cause it will take you forever to get that money back if your only cash flowing around $300 or $400 a month, you cant buy a property every 7 or 10 years doing the conventional method of buying a house, so you almost got to rehab the house and either flip or get it appraised for more and cash refi to get your money back and rent it out, i dont know how everyone making money, please dont say seller finace, cause that dont exist

 Seems like you are telling us there is no way.  Give up.  Do not ask questions and educate.  It’s impossible.  RE is not for you.  

RE has many different strategies.  Seller financing does not exist?  I guess that is one less property that I own.  Buy direct from seller, 4 less properties.  Good brrrr/value add, 8 less.  

As has already been stated owner occupied is an easy way to enter with minimal down. Naca is full of hurdles and has a learning curve. Have you looked into it. How about traditional FHA? High LTV combined with house hacking including by room, STE/mtr, or traditional LTR.

Non-owner occupied there are value adds, BRRRR, Partnering, arbitrage to name a few. Any of which could result in none of your investment being trapped in the investment. Same rent options as house hacking.

This really is just the Beginning of RE strategies as I concentrated on one that does not commit significant funds long. 

There are numerous passive options that trap funds but have produced great returns: syndication, mineral rights (We timed our acquisition perfect and had ~40% return on investment on year 1), NNN, Notes, REITS, etc.

You need to educate on possibilities rather than it is not possible (pessimism is not your ally.  It is possible.  Many people on this site are proof it is possible.  

Good luck

Hard to get seller financing,  i ask 2 realtors about that and they laughed and said your not going to find any one to do that, brrrr is the really only strategy i see, hear alot of haters saying oh there are tons of ways, but i dont see any body throwing numbers out there for examples

I think like the posts above say, you need to be more open-minded. It also can take a lot of time to find the right property to start with. I have 3 multifamily deals on the go right now, all of which are seller-financed for the entire down payment. It's 560 doors in total. 

Be open-minded. Don't just think that the 2 realtors you've talked to know what they're talking about. You've come to a forum to ask questions, and people are going to give you their honest feedback and experience. 


 My issue is he is not asking questions.  He already knows seller financing is impossible.  He has not asked about how to find it because why would you ask when it is impossible?

He also seems fixated on seller financing as though that is the only low/no Money option.  The book by Brandon must be full of empty pages. I have never read this book but interesting a book with nothing on its pages could sell any copies.  hmmm!


 That's a VERY good point. To be honest, I'm not sure why someone would come on a site like this if they already know so much more than the rest of the members. Good point Dan, good point. I listened to that book as an audiobook. I thought there were words in it, but maybe I was just listening to white noise for 10 hours. I'll have to go double-check! haha.

Post: LVP or carpet in upstairs units

Matt CalnanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Lethbridge, Alberta
  • Posts 26
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Abiy Tedla:

We're currently in the process of renovating a top level apartment unit in a 2 floor building and debating on whether to go with carpet for noise reduction or LVP for looks and durability.  My preference is LVP but our PM has suggested to go with carpet on the top units to reduce noise complaints.  Any tips and experiences on using LVP with minimal noise would be greatly appreciated.  I figured that the BP community would be the best folks to ask about this!  Thanks!


I would ALWAYS go LVP. The only carpet I put in units is commercial carpet, but it's more expensive than LVP. And you can get good underlay for cheap with LVP that will dampen the sound for you. I'd rather have the durability of LVP or commercial carpet and hear about a noise complaint every so often then to replace crappy carpet every 3 years!

Post: Multifamily investment in New Jersey

Matt CalnanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Lethbridge, Alberta
  • Posts 26
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Joval Mathai:

Am I the only one who refresh Zillow every 10mins ! What are the best ways to find a listing ? 


One strategy I've found that works well in the past is driving around, finding a property that is clearly a rental (a bit rundown, lawn not taken care of, etc.), then pulling the title for the properties that I find. Often on the other end of the conversation is a landlord who is not happy with dealing with tenants anymore and has "given up" on driving by and making sure the property is taken care of. 

It certainly doesn't work all the time, but usually 15-20% of the time I get somewhere in terms of a discussion. I usually do that with larger multifamily properties, but it would work even better with smaller ones I would think!

Post: Help please! First time multifamily/commercial investor

Matt CalnanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Lethbridge, Alberta
  • Posts 26
  • Votes 7

Hey @Paul O'Connor

Congrats on the opportunity first of all. There are some really good due diligence lists out there that you could tap into. They will be REALLY comprehensive and you likely won't have to follow everything in there, but I always think it's rather to start with too much and widdle it down. Here is a high level example:

https://northeastpcg.com/blog/...

To answer your questions above specifically:
1) Yes, RO systems exist for well water. There should be a lot of companies in your area that offer this service. Have someone come out and take a look, it should be relatively inexpensive to complete. 

2) This is up to you and your leases. Usually on commercial properties you have CAM (common area maintenance) expenses which are fully paid proportionately by the tenants (based on square footage). However, mixed with multifamily you will likely want to allocate some of this expense either as a fee to the residential tenants, or more likely, an expense to the building/company itself. 

3) It depends on how your utilities are set up - do you have separate electric/water/gas meters? If so, then I always like to have tenants pay for utilities. What is typically more common (not always though) in multifamily is that some utilities will be included because they won't be separately metered. However, I would always ensure the commercial tenants are paying for their utilities. If it isn't separately metered for them, come up with some type of distribution of charges that you have in the lease. One important note - the common area utilities can be charged back to the commercial tenants through the CAM, though again you may need to pay a portion of these CAM expenses for the residential tenants. 

4) I have never seen a municipality that didn't have a fee associated with sewage. It should be easy enough to figure out though, just call the municipality and they'll be able to answer that for you.

5) Again, usually there is a fee for this, or it is included in your property taxes. But when dealing with commercial/multifamily property, you almost always have to have separate waste disposal. Again, a call to the municipality will quickly clear that up for you.

For due diligence, like I said there are some really comprehensive documents out there. But at a high level, I want to know property taxes, insurance, and utilities historically (and most importantly, VERIFY THESE YOURSELF). Historic vacancy rates, rental rates (are they increasing, staying the same, etc.), and issues with tenants. It's also really important to know the maintenance status of the building. Has it been well maintained, or are the owners trying to pinch pennies everywhere - which will now become your problem? What kind of plumbing and electrical exists? How is the roof? Is it wood building, brick, or concrete? What does the boiler/hot water/furnace look like? Have they been maintained? Do they need to be replaced relatively soon? 

Usually, on this type of property, you're going to need an appraisal and an inspection. But even if those aren't required, I'd always recommend getting the inspection done. It can help you stay away from a bad deal. Good luck with everything! 

Post: REDFIN - sharing recent experience

Matt CalnanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Lethbridge, Alberta
  • Posts 26
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:
Quote from @Debra Dee:

I live in Albuquerque NM and have investment property here, and a great agent that I enjoy working with here. I am the executor of my aunt's estate, who passed away last year, and recently was tasked with selling her home in Arizona. For many years, I worked in the real estate industry and managed a very large residential firm in southern CA and worked closely with several of the highest producing agents in our market at the time. Needless to say, I am a probably pickier than most, or can see right through some of the questionable sales tactics that some agents use. I was a little bit familiar with Redfin but had no prior personal or professional experience with the company. As it turned out, they listed and sold another home on the same block where my aunt's former home is located. I was curious about their sale, so I called the agent with the listing, and ended up hiring her to list my aunt's house also. She answered my call professionally, didn't rush me on the phone, promptly sent me a top-notch CMA and market stats, and as she promised, a coordinator from their office reached out to me the same day to schedule an in-person meeting at my aunt's house while I was in town. Redfin agent arrived on time, nice clean car, dressed professionally, and I was immediately impressed with her understanding of the shifting market, the recent sales nearby, and she made a few suggestions to enhance the curb appeal and interior, which I completely agreed when she pointed them out. At the end of the appointment, I was planning to tell her that I'd get back to her and would speak to 1 or 2 other agents before making a decision. Instead, I hired her right then and there. She demonstrated her professionalism, knowledge, responsiveness and resourcefulness, and I had a good feeling that I could count on her to do a good job. She was great. The other Redfin staff were on top of it and equally responsive. From start to finish, they did a great job. They delivered a high-quality experience, with marketing materials and customer service frequently only found in the luxury market, which this was not. They sold the home for more than what I was expecting and had it under contract in only 3 weeks.

I've seen some comments on this site and others that refer to Redfin as a discount brokerage or a company for lazy agents, since they pay a base salary and provide benefits, or a company that offers less so they charge less. Redfin has a different business model, but the company provides more marketing services and invests millions in online marketing and a robust website than any of the other big real estate brands. The support staff that Redfin has working on every transaction helps move them much more smoothly towards closing than when individual agents are trying to wear too many hats at once and make mistakes when stretched thin in too many directions. Anyways, wanted to put the word out there about how impressed I was with the overall experience and quality of services that Redfin provided me recently.


 my impression is redfin is good as buyer agent but for listing agent I would think twice because they are very lazy as you said lol


 Agreed with this. Great to buy with!

Post: Value of land vs. house

Matt CalnanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Lethbridge, Alberta
  • Posts 26
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Lauren Seeley:

Hi! My bf and I are looking to purchase a house to live in Boynon Beach, Florida. I currently own a condo that I would rent out full time. We found a house for ~$1.05MM that has an amazing 1/2 acre lot, pool and on a canal that leads into a lake  - but the house itself is small (1400 sq ft) and while it’s livable it does need a bit of work which we can do over time. Because the house is on the smaller size, it is about 762 price per sq ft which is almost double the average we’re seeing in that neighborhood with other houses that are NOT on the water and have half the size of the Lot. Other houses that are on that same canal and have 1/4 acre of land (1/2 the size of the land) are closer to 650 per square ft.  We are trying to assess how to factor the value of the land into that equation to see if it’s worth it or not to buy. Any help or guidance would be much appreciated!

Thanks,


Lauren


 It would be worth looking at vacant lots/plots of land in the area to see what they are selling for. If you can break that down /acre or psf, then you can subtract that value off the psf cost of your house. Compare that to other psf values of similar properties like you've done, taking into account their land value as well. 

Post: How to play bidding war ?

Matt CalnanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Lethbridge, Alberta
  • Posts 26
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Carlos Ptriawan:

Hi Folks, we already listed our home and had 2-weekend open house and we got multiple bid already, so we got multiple bids on DOM 4. Aftre that we decide to set up a due date, but the offer is very strong , and slightly above asking. Price is very close to a mil. This is a very niche condo within walking distance to the top ten CA High schools with the fully rehabbed condition. This is also one of the most popular homes in Redfin for this week. Do you guys think it's safe to reject the initial offer and use the due date to gather more bids or we just accept the pre-emptive bid that's coming? How to play it out ?


 I'm curious as to how this ended up for you. Obviously, it all comes down to your risk level. I always think about the potential upside vs. the potential downside. I'd rather secure the funds sooner (especially if it is above asking - you're getting more than you initially thought) and get moving with new projects and never look back. 

Post: Financing Advice /Tips

Matt CalnanPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Lethbridge, Alberta
  • Posts 26
  • Votes 7
Quote from @Nadya Babanskaya:
Quote from @Taylor Dasch:

Hey great question and I am still trying to figure out the best way to go about this as well. 

1. Conventional loans can be good especially when you are first starting out or refinancing out of HML or PML. I did this for my first rental and it has the lowest interest rate in my investment portfolio. I wouldnt be too worried about making the offer look less attractive than a cash offer as the market isnt nearly as competitive as it was last year. The advantage of a cash offer is getting a discount on the property.

2. If I had the option, and was very comfortable with my market(which I am) I would go this route. I like the idea of a HELOC - I dont have to worry about the high fees for HML/PML. If you have enough to do the full PP and rehab, I would use the HELOC to pay for the property - hopefully at 75%, then refinance and pay the HELOC back, rinse and repeat. This seems like it will be the least expensive way to go about this because you should be able to keep using the HELOC for that purpose. But it sounds like you want to get something a little more turn key so this may not be an option - even then though, leveraging the HELOC could get you much more in terms of cash flow.

#2 is the better option in my opinion because it allows you the ability to scale. 


Thank you, that’s the one I’ve been leaning towards, especially considering the ability to scale. It is definitely the more risky option with a few moving parts and hoping everything falls into place though 😬


 I would agree, number 2 gives so much more flexibility. And yes it has a higher interest rate as people have pointed out, but with no principal payments required, the cash flow will be much stronger than traditional term debt.