@Sean Yang
Gentlemen, please allow me to tie up some loose ends from the discussion above. First, Sean, no, the real estate agent license and mortgage brokers license are different things. The Mortgage Broker is subject to Dodd-Frank regulations. The real problem is that he didn't broker a mortgage to you it was to the investor. To you, he might have been an investment counselor asking you to get into an unregulated investment without proper disclosures. If you are not an accredited investor, this is particularly troublesome. You might have some recourse against him via SEC violations. That would be the long way around and may never come to any result for you.
Foreclosing or threatening to foreclose is not your best option, depending on the state regulations and the determination of the buyer you could get tied up for years in an hourly attorney fee. BTW- your first check should be with the recorder of deeds. It is possible and, it actually happens with unbelievable frequency, your "2nd" mortgage lien might actually have been recorded in 1st position! If that happened, you can sit back and wait for somebody to pay you (provided the taxes stay current). If it didn't you need to get busy protecting your position and negotiating a solution.A collection agency is not the way to go. All they do is hound the debtor for a commission and if they can’t collect they either give up or recommend a lower level agency that wants more commission. Eventually, somebody will sue the buyer for you but you won’t get more than a dime on the dollar if they are able to collect at all. If you want to do this you are better off to sell the note to somebody who buys non-performing mortgages for a fee (typically 40-60 cents on the dollar) and then the problem is his.
The rest of this is right in my wheelhouse so feel free to contact me about this. Let me splain. . . .No, there is too much, let me sum up. . . .
The HML is not really out that much money because $300,000 is in escrow! The HML and claim his escrow and walk away with the property by foreclosing and be pretty much whole even by selling the property at a deep discount at foreclosure. Your concern is getting your value back anyway you can, not in having the borrower pay. There are so many options my head is spinning at the sheer number of ways for you to come out ahead on this deal. @Bruce May is right the HML doesn’t want to foreclose. You could buy the mortgage from the HML at a discount if you have the cash and there are ways for you to get the cash. You could take a deed in lieu of foreclosure from the buyer and guarantee the HML yourself on negotiated terms. If your credit position is good you could then refinance the whole deal and handle it yourself or sell it by simply giving the HML his $300,000 back with terms on the $200,000.
You could still have a claim against the buyer the whole time and if he is really reputable he might make arrangements to pay you. More likely, he is in a bad position all around. You said that his business is belly up. Perhaps he has equity in another project that you could take over and finish for a profit beyond your investment? That could be a great solution for you! You get a workable project and he gets out of your debt only to deal with the HML.
You must start to get creative or somebody smarter is going to take advantage of what I personally think is an ideal situation as a buyer and they will come offer you a short sale. Given the costs you are likely to incur if you go to court, that short sale will be your lifeline.
I can think of about a hundred ways to make this deal work to your advantage or at least get you mostly whole. You just have to find the one that works best for you!
I hope this helps! Holler if you need me.
Best regards,
Mark