Hello BP, I purchased a legal 2-fam house in the Bronx (built in 1899) with an illegal attic unit that's a finished apartment with plans to househack and live in that unit and rent out the others. Right after closing 2 months ago, I went straight into renovations and didn't schedule an inspection til afterwards. Unfortunately, the house was vacant after reno since I haven't gotten tenants in yet nor have I moved in (was planning on it) and I failed interior insurance inspection due to a vacant house and illegal unit. The insurance apparently won't consider reinstating as per my insurance broker.
How can I ensure I pass my next inspection? What is the proper way to decommission the illegal unit and is this absolutely necessary? Would I have to temporarily move to one of the legal units? Would future insurances I inquire always see a history of a failed inspection? For reference, the illegal attic unit has a gas stove, 1st floor has a gas stove, and I JUST converted the 2nd floor unit to fully electric and capped the gas line. The illegal unit is accessed at the top of a shared staircase as the 3rd floor. It has its own door and looks like its own independent apartment.
I'd appreciate any advice and help I can get. Current insurance is going to lapse next week.