@Clint Weir haha! Thank you Clint! No plans to move to Texas anytime soon but thank you for your kind words. Feel free to DM anytime if I can help with anything.
@Jonathan Minerick Thanks for sharing Jon! In the interest of full disclosure, I think it's fair to share with the forum that you are one of those MLS entry only brokers here in San Diego. So, I totally understand that you believe in your business model, just as believe in mine. Thank you for also correcting me about the data aggregation. I am aware that some companies like yours are able to aggregate to a handful of sites. Currently my listings will go out to over 1,100 sites internationally, translated in to the local languages. I don't think it's necessary for me to share the entire comprehensive Global Luxury marketing program that a powerful brand like Coldwell Banker can offer. What I can say is that when sellers are shown the differences between almost no marketing for their property and what agents like me can offer, there is one reason why they are willing to pay a 5% or 6% commission; it's because they see the value.
The job of a larger, traditional brokerage is not to just be more expensive. But, to provide more exposure, which leads to more potential buyers, more offers, and a higher closed sale price. In some markets, as many as 30% of buyers are coming from another country, especially in higher price points. Without international marketing, you're missing exposure almost a 1/3 of potential qualified buyers. Your company only charges $95 to enter the property in the MLS. Which, might seem like a great deal. But, since you don't have any marketing budget built into the commission, how will you pay for $1,500 it cost to put it on sites Juwai? China has an internet firewall against sites like Zillow so not all buyers are shopping online that way.
Also, to clarify your statement that the listing agent never brings the buyer and just put it in the MLS and let the buyer's agents do their job... First, most agents are not strictly buyers agents OR listing agents. Most take listings as well as work with buyers. Some tend to lean in one direction or the other but unless you're on a team that dictates you job title, we work with both. Yes, it's a statistical probability that when a listing agent puts a house on the market that they will cooperate with another agent that brings the buyer. But it's more common than you may think that a listing agent is the one to bring the buyer. I don't know the exact statistic, that's a personal observation from watch the closed listings in the MLS hotsheet daily. Probably 1 out of every 10 that I see is dual agency.
Either way, I believe it's the listing agent's responsibility to drive traffic to the listing through their marketing efforts. In today's global market, I don't believe the MLS and a handful of websites is doing a seller justice to get them maximum exposure and therefore the highest price. One way a potential seller can gauge whether the listing agent is worth their commission is to ask about their list to close price ratio. Mine is currently 98.1%. Which means when I list a property that it closes, on average for 98.1% of the asking price. If you're talking to an agent that usually only sells property for 91% or 93% of the asking price (which is the average here in San Diego) then you can see they would they house for 5-7% more with a traditional agent. They don't have to do the work of an agent and still end up netting more from the sale.
There are times that I have actually recommended companies like yours to people. Like in the case of an experienced flipper that wants to quickly list a house in a hot market and it will get multiple offers within a few days just by being on the MLS. But, most sellers have full time jobs and aren't doing themselves a favor by taking on the time consuming and constant work of marketing, showing and negotiating the sale of a home only to end up selling for less. Not to mention the skills & experience it takes to negotiate the highest price and best terms. When other agents or a potential buyer sees my listing in the MLS, they can call me and I'll always answer the phone or be available to meet them on short notice because this is my full time job. The sellers who are doing showings themselves take on a lot of stress and potentially miss showings that need to happen on short notice. Just like in the case of a For Sale By Owner listing, if the buyers agent knows the seller is not having to pay commission to the list side, they will often reduce the offer price by the amount of that commission to result in the same cash-at-close as if you would have hired an agent.
If MLS entry only or discount commission brokerage models were effective in every situation and market, I'm sure I would be out of a job by now because everyone would be using them. But, I believe that what I offer is pretty valuable.
Off my soap box now... :) Thanks again for your feedback. Have a great week!