thanks all for the advice.
So the current rents w/ heat included are below market average, by making the tenants pay their own heat some of them will still need to be raised
Current break down is below
Unit 1 1/1 - Lease thru Mar-13 w/ heat @ $730 long term tenant 4+yrs
Unit 2 1/1 - Lease thru Jun-13 w/ heat @ $940 tenant for last 2 yrs
Unit 3 1/1 - TAW w/ heat @ $925 long term tenant 4+ years
Unit 4 2/1 - Vacant
Based on my review of the market the 1/1 units should rent for $900-1000 unheated and the 2/1 for $1200-1300 unheated.
I would like to keep the existing tenants if possible because I have received feedback that they pay on time and keep the place in decent shape. I am considering keeping the tenants at 940 and 925 however requiring them to pay their own heat. The tenant at $730 will be bumped to $950 unheated and may not stay.
When I did the home inspection the heat in one of the units was set obnoxiously high, 80+ and I called the oil company who told me in the last year they provided over 3,000 gallons to the house. I will certainly have a friendly conversation with each tenant when I take over the house in Dec and ask to be smart with temperature. However I am limited by their current leases which do not mention any discretion.
Any other thoughts you guys have is greatly appreciated!
Thanks,
Mike