Thanks to everyone that joined the conversation... ahhh, as always lots of conflicting information but that was to be expected.
@Michael Baum, I did like the area too and had a good time there. The sandbags also concerned me and I would be looking in other parts of town for sure. Sedona is pretty but also even more expensive, so I didn't even consider it. Do you have any insight on the Boise area or other ID areas? We did visit Boise earlier this year (its driving distance from my inlaws which makes it nice) and really liked it there too. Clean, friendly, activity rich and lots of employment driving growth as far as I found.
And yes, @Andrew Steffens, @Ashish Acharya, @Account Closed, I truly would be interested in giving STR a shot but I do worry about being far away from it as well as new regulations being put into place (like here where we live they are in the process of pretty much eliminating any STRs completely). The main reason why I would want to ensure it can cover itself as an LTR in case.
So much to learn, so much to think about... I appreciate all the food for thought! Kristin