Well - I actually own the same house next door and rent it out as a vacation rental. 50% of the rents definitely do not go to rental expenses.. It's less. Maybe 50% if you are using a property management company but I do not. if you want clear facts on vacation rental breakdowns I can provide that as thats what I currently do w my other house.
Here are the details for my other house, and the reason why I am considering buying the 2nd.
Yearly PITI: roughly $28,000
Yearly association fee: $2500
Cleaning fees (paid by renters)
Yearly average utilities (cable, phone, heat, electric): $3240
Yearly advertising costs (vrbo/homeaway.com etc): $600
Total costs: $34400
The house rents solid 3 months in the summer and 3 months in the winter. It also rents during every holiday period. I will not include random off season rentals as they are gravy to me..
A summer week = $1500
A winter week = $1700
Holidays are a bit higher
A full summer season = roughly $18,000
A full winter season = roughly $24,000
Random other holidays = $4,000
Total yearly rentals = $46,000
Total yearly profit = $11,600
Now granted this is assuming full occupancy during high season, assuming some vacancy, you could round down to $8-10k a year profit.
With that being said - my neighbors house is currently for sale.. and seeing how well I do with mine, I don't feel that it is a bad investment. I honestly got into it thinking as long as I didn't lose money I'd be happy - for other investments I do expect at least 100-200 month profit as a general rule of thumb. But those are smaller 100k properties. I guess I figured if I was able to have the rents pay the mortgage for a 330k house, I would be doing pretty well - considering in 10-15 years (if I was making extra payments towards the mortgage) I would have 330k in equity.
Does that make sense now, my reason for wanting to buy it? Does it seem like a better investment from that point of view now? I know it goes against the typical grain of investing, but I think it's worthwhile.
I definitely woudlnt do anything "creative" that would violate my code of ethics. Thats why I am asking for suggestions - LEGAL/ETHICAL suggestions lol.. Also - to answer your question, the retail value for this house is around 350k so I am getting it right around retail value - but even at that, am still managing to make a profit.
And lastly, as far as taking over the payments on the current mortgage, I am not sure I am clear on how that works? The mortgage never gets transferred into my name but the deed gets recorded as transferred? This doesnt quite sound safe to me - who has more of a risk doing it this way, myself or the seller? and if so, what risks are involved and how does one get a seller to agree to such a thing? Sounds complicated/slightly shady almost but that may be because I am unfamiliar with the process.