@Brent Coombs you nailed it on the head. If I find out that I bid 1,000 too low then I will be frustrated. On the other hand if I get it I'll be like, "Ouch, I over bid". LOL and who said this wouldn't be fun! There is definitely emotion involved here but it isn't the kind that is driving me to get the house at any cost. The process of highest and best is what is driving me crazy and unless the winning bid is much higher than what we end up bidding, what ever happens I know I'll think I should have bid either a bit more or a bit less.
All the input is great. I agree with @Will Barnard that my soft costs may be a touch low and I need to check DOM. Financing is with HELOC and those costs will be about $500 per month. So now we have closing cost on the purchase, utilities & insurance left. Depending on how long it takes to sell my estimate could be low.
If this house was listed for $95K I would have offered full price but since it was listed for $76,400 it is bizarre to me to bid so much over listing. Of course there is the whole, "Does someone know something I don't." scenario too.
We have to make a decision later today so I'll update the thread on how it goes.
Thanks and enjoy the day . . . it is beautiful here in Ohio.
Kevin