TL;DR - First investment property is a major rehab. Good idea or bad idea?
I'm looking at a post-WW2 house that hasn't been occupied for roughly a decade. No running water, no electricity. I am in talks with the brother of the owner (kept in the family since it was built). They are considering their options for what to finally do to offload the property. I'm trying to position myself as their best choice, considering I live next door.
Here's a list of issues, in no particular order:
* Nonconforming floor space. The county still sees this house as a 2bd/1ba and 720 sqft. Neither of these are true any more. If I was able to get permits and pass inspection on everything, it would be a 4bd/3ba with 2080 sqft. (basement digout + additions) I got confirmation from a county assessor that I would not be liable for back taxes, so I feel that the only hurdle would be the permitting process.
* Cost of rehab. My roommate has been a handyman for over 15 years, and led the rehab on a property this year less than 5 miles away. I trust his ability to quote a ballpark estimate of rehab costs and he thinks $100k is a reasonable estimate. Did I mention the property was unoccupied for a decade? Leaking roof, vagrants cutting out plumbing/electric, old shingles...if the foundation weren't solid, I'd only consider scraping it.
* I'm cash poor. Just got off paternity leave with my first, and I'll have less than $10k available for any kind of down payment on a loan. On the bright side, I expect my house would appraise for at least $150k more than what I paid for it. I bought at $285k, upgraded from 3/1.5 to 3/2, and a smaller 3/2 on my block sold for $435k in March. One option could be getting hard money for the purchase and fund the rehab with a HELOC. Is that my best option? Not sure. I would consider owner-financing during rehab if my girlfriend were working...but without income on her end, I'm concerned about having the cashflow to make it work. (Net income of $2000/month after bills, taxes, and groceries.)
* Best price to offer? If everything works perfectly, I'd have a rent-ready 4/3 by this time next year. I feel like my main risk is the basement space being too shallow to pass inspection. In which case, I'd have a 3/2 with nonconforming space...and I already have a comp on my block to tell me what that value probably will be. I'm leaning towards offering 75% of ARV of a 3/2, minus 150% of rehab costs. That comes out to between 175-200k. I hope this is a valid estimate.
I am placing a lot of emotional weight on the idea of owning two adjacent properties: one for my family, one as a rental. This feels appealing, because I can keep a lot of things close to the status quo. (e.g. roommates can just move next door) But starting RE investing with a rehab project of this scope will definitely force me to learn a lot of things very quickly. I'm sure I still have some blind spots, but I don't know what else to research at this point to cover what I've overlooked before I make an offer. Any help would be appreciated.