Skip to content
×
Pro Members Get
Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
ANNUAL Save 54%
$32.50 /mo
$390 billed annualy
MONTHLY
$69 /mo
billed monthly
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
×
Try Pro Features for Free
Start your 7 day free trial. Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties.
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Kyle Deutschmann

Kyle Deutschmann has started 8 posts and replied 372 times.

Post: Who is your go-to title company for 'subject-to' deals?

Kyle Deutschmann
Posted
  • Lender
  • Baltimore, MD
  • Posts 402
  • Votes 197

@Andrew Postell I specifically posted this question on BiggerPockets rather than the local "Maryland Investors Network" on Facebook or other local groups because these "sub 2" deals are frequently talked about on the BiggerPockets podcast and in the forums, yet I have never seen anyone truly explain how this works and the legality behind it. @Tom Gimer and @Ron S. you have helped to clarify a lot of my questions on here. I look forward to scheduling some time to chat with you Tom. 

Post: Who is your go-to title company for 'subject-to' deals?

Kyle Deutschmann
Posted
  • Lender
  • Baltimore, MD
  • Posts 402
  • Votes 197
Quote from @Ron S.:
Quote from @Kyle Deutschmann:
Quote from @Ron S.:
Quote from @Kyle Deutschmann:


 Thanks for contributing here. Are you a private lender or more conventional? 

That all makes sense - I used to be a conventional LO but never worked on the secondary side or as a private lender. I've been told mixed things on if and when a lender will/won't call a loan due in these types of scenarios. 

A wholesaler showed me his closing docs a while back and it basically made the new owner look like a property manager making payments and the new insurance still included the original mortgagee clause and loan # as far as I know.. think that would help at all? They actually informed the lender upfront who would be making payments, etc. Not sure how that all ended up down the line.. 

@Tom Gimer -  yeah it sounds like it makes sense as a short term strategy. How long would you say it takes for someone like Ron to come in and torpedo the deal? 

Conventional lender.
The mortgagee clause and loan number don't hurt but, the "insured" changes. That's our "aha" moment.


Gotcha makes sense. An agent I talked to recently recommended the buyer close in a trust thinking that helps somehow.. any idea if that makes any difference here? How long does the process take when you catch one of these? How long does the buyer/seller have to pay off that loan before the lender files a lawsuit or foreclosure (or whatever legal remedy they have?)


 4 months to start (CFPB 120 day rule), then state specific for sale so, in California, another 3 months for the publishing period, then 21 days for sale notice so, about 7 months once I catch you, best case, meaning, i probably wont' catch you right away and when i do,  i send a demand to the original borrower to tell them they have 30 days to put it back, then i start my 120 days acceleration period after that. If a person can't get a deal flipped in that time, probably should be in a different line of work.


 This is super helpful. Thank you for your insights here. 

Post: Who is your go-to title company for 'subject-to' deals?

Kyle Deutschmann
Posted
  • Lender
  • Baltimore, MD
  • Posts 402
  • Votes 197
Quote from @Ron S.:
Quote from @Kyle Deutschmann:


 Thanks for contributing here. Are you a private lender or more conventional? 

That all makes sense - I used to be a conventional LO but never worked on the secondary side or as a private lender. I've been told mixed things on if and when a lender will/won't call a loan due in these types of scenarios. 

A wholesaler showed me his closing docs a while back and it basically made the new owner look like a property manager making payments and the new insurance still included the original mortgagee clause and loan # as far as I know.. think that would help at all? They actually informed the lender upfront who would be making payments, etc. Not sure how that all ended up down the line.. 

@Tom Gimer -  yeah it sounds like it makes sense as a short term strategy. How long would you say it takes for someone like Ron to come in and torpedo the deal? 

Conventional lender.
The mortgagee clause and loan number don't hurt but, the "insured" changes. That's our "aha" moment.


Gotcha makes sense. An agent I talked to recently recommended the buyer close in a trust thinking that helps somehow.. any idea if that makes any difference here? How long does the process take when you catch one of these? How long does the buyer/seller have to pay off that loan before the lender files a lawsuit or foreclosure (or whatever legal remedy they have?)

Post: Who is your go-to title company for 'subject-to' deals?

Kyle Deutschmann
Posted
  • Lender
  • Baltimore, MD
  • Posts 402
  • Votes 197
Quote from @Ron S.:
Quote from @Tom Gimer:

@Ron S. Haven't seen you here in a while until lately. You wanna chime in on lender/servicer types, the DOS and subject-to?

 Hehe....long time Tom!

My two cents as a lender - I still call them every time I catch them. How do I catch them? I catch them when they change the name and/or mailing address on the property assessors tax role. Why? Because I (I, meaning as a lender) monitor the property for taxes to ensure they are being paid (Assuming I'm not paying them through impounds). I also catch them when they (The buyer) get insurance. Why? Because I also monitor the insurance to make sure I'm the mortgagee, and that there is adequate coverage acceptable to me, and that the deductible isn't too high. I catch them when the payment changes and the buyer isn't aware because they aren't the borrower. I catch them when the mailing address changes. I catch them when the buyer tries to set up automatic payments from an account that doesn't match borrower name. I catch them when i'm skiptracing and get in contact with the previous owner where they disclose they sold the property Subject to, in violation of the terms of my note.

Why do I care as a lender? Because the buyer isn't able to get any information on the loan and isn't compelled to comply with the covenants of the loan because they probably don't want to and because they don't know what those covenants are. Because I more than likely pledged that loan to FHLB and I can't pledge a loan where my owner is different than my borrower so it puts me out of compliance with them. Because many of my loans are sold to investors (Including Fannie/Freddie) that also have issues with owners not being the borrowers and by not enforcing my DOS, I'm out of compliance with my seller/servicer agreements. Because a Sub To is a violation of the note and DOT and I subject myself to fair lending and UDAAP scrutiny by not enforcing the note. Because @Corby Goade has some good points that people get involved with these deals and know just enough to get in to trouble and when there is trouble, they get to walk away from it with little exposure/liability and leave a path of destruction in their wake if it doesn't work.

 Thanks for contributing here. Are you a private lender or more conventional? 

That all makes sense - I used to be a conventional LO but never worked on the secondary side or as a private lender. I've been told mixed things on if and when a lender will/won't call a loan due in these types of scenarios. 

A wholesaler showed me his closing docs a while back and it basically made the new owner look like a property manager making payments and the new insurance still included the original mortgagee clause and loan # as far as I know.. think that would help at all? They actually informed the lender upfront who would be making payments, etc. Not sure how that all ended up down the line.. 

@Tom Gimer -  yeah it sounds like it makes sense as a short term strategy. How long would you say it takes for someone like Ron to come in and torpedo the deal? 

Post: Who is your go-to title company for 'subject-to' deals?

Kyle Deutschmann
Posted
  • Lender
  • Baltimore, MD
  • Posts 402
  • Votes 197
Quote from @Corby Goade:
Quote from @Kyle Deutschmann:

Hey BP community, 

For anyone who has done a subject-to deal in central MD... who is your go-to title company for this type of transaction? 

Also, has anyone had any issues with lenders calling these loans due on sale? How do you get around this and not screw over the seller? 

I understand VA and FHA loans are assumable... This is not what I'm talking about - I'm referring to buying a property subject-to the existing (conventional or commercial) financing. I've seen a credible title company close one of these in Nashville where I used to live, but have never dealt with this in MD where I currently live.

Thank you in advance for your comments and suggestions. BP typically doesn't allow self-promotion, so if you are a title rep who has experience with this, feel free to slide in my DMs. 


 This question is asked and answered (incorrectly) IMHO on here daily. 

Every title company is happy to do creative deals, they just don't want to work with people who create problems for them. Here's how it normally works:


-New investor finds an assignment contract online, downloads it, has no idea how it works or what the terms of the contract are. 

-They find someone who agrees to sell them a property sub to or OWC, everyone signs the crappy contract, no one understands what they are doing. 

-Buyer sends the contract to their "investor friendly" title company.

-Seller's cousin, sister, neighbor, kids and their high school history teacher all find out that the seller is "being taken advantage of and having their property stolen by a sleazy real estate investor."

-They all start calling the title company, showing up, threatening legal action, etc. 

-Title company tells investor that they don't want to work with them any more. 

-Investor thinks the title company doesn't do "creative" deals. The reality is the investor is throwing a huge liability at the title company and the juice isn't worth the squeeze. 

If you are honest, knowledgeable and humble, any title company will work your contracts. Proactively reach out to escrow officers in your market, buy them lunch and ask them questions. That'll be the best up front investment you can make. 

Finally, people will tell you that loans NEVER get called. I've heard of a few happening recently and a friend of mine just had one called on a sub to deal last week. It can and does happen, so plan accordingly. Assumptions are infinitely better for everyone than sub to if you can make it happen. 

Best of luck!

Thanks for your insights. I agree that this subject is asked about frequently, but no one on the podcast (at least that I've heard) has discussed how this really works and how they get 'around' the due on sale clause and other obvious things that make this less than an ideal strategy. I have talked to a few local title agents who either do not understand this strategy or don't feel like it's worth the liability when they could focus on regular/retail business. 

I have a few contacts I'm going to discuss this with. Was there anything unique about their situation or commonality such as the particular lender or loan servicer, or a particularly low rate perhaps held by a smaller bank on their portfolio? And how much time do they give you to pay the loan off when they call it due? 

Post: Who is your go-to title company for 'subject-to' deals?

Kyle Deutschmann
Posted
  • Lender
  • Baltimore, MD
  • Posts 402
  • Votes 197
Quote from @Tom Gimer:

@Kyle Deutschmann You're not going to find a good title company to handle FHA and VA sub-to work because by definition they would be ignorant of federal guidance on the issue. Is ignorant good? I don't think so. Before too long there will be a default, foreclosure and PMI claim… then an investigation. End result is they'll be blackballed from closing transactions involving federally backed mortgages.

Actually took me a while to research, find and post that guidance. If I recall it may precede the internet. 

Thank you for your input. If you read my original post I said I am not referring to assumable FHA and VA loans.. 

Post: Who is your go-to title company for 'subject-to' deals?

Kyle Deutschmann
Posted
  • Lender
  • Baltimore, MD
  • Posts 402
  • Votes 197
Quote from @Andrew Postell:

@Kyle Deutschmann go to your local real estate meetup groups. If we know what we need, but need it in our area, we need to go local. Meetup.com is a good resource for those but some of the groups will also post here on Bigger Pockets Marketplace too. Even facebook might have some good local groups for you. But post locally for this. That’s the best bet.

 Thank you.. I hosted a meetup with ~ 30 in attendance this past Thursday. There was only one title rep, and she wasn't super familiar with closing a property subject to existing financing. Have you worked with any title companies in your market who has helped your investor clients close these types of deals? Or from your experience in lending, have you ever heard of lenders calling these loans due on sale? I heard it can take such a long time and cost to foreclose that most of your investors would rather just turn a blind eye and keep accepting the payments as long as they are coming in on time. 

Post: Who is your go-to title company for 'subject-to' deals?

Kyle Deutschmann
Posted
  • Lender
  • Baltimore, MD
  • Posts 402
  • Votes 197

Hey BP community, 

For anyone who has done a subject-to deal in central MD... who is your go-to title company for this type of transaction? 

Also, has anyone had any issues with lenders calling these loans due on sale? How do you get around this and not screw over the seller? 

I understand VA and FHA loans are assumable... This is not what I'm talking about - I'm referring to buying a property subject-to the existing (conventional or commercial) financing. I've seen a credible title company close one of these in Nashville where I used to live, but have never dealt with this in MD where I currently live.

Thank you in advance for your comments and suggestions. BP typically doesn't allow self-promotion, so if you are a title rep who has experience with this, feel free to slide in my DMs. 

Post: Getting Started, DMV and Gulf Shores

Kyle Deutschmann
Posted
  • Lender
  • Baltimore, MD
  • Posts 402
  • Votes 197

Hey Frank, welcome and thank you for your service! This is definitely possible, but it sounds like your DTI might be a bit high to purchase a primary residence unless you use a co-signer or pay off some of your other debts first. However, if you use a DSCR loan for the rental property then you can qualify based on the rents the property will/is currently bringing in compared to the monthly payment (PITI+HOA) instead of qualifying based on your DTI. I've been told DSCR (non-owner occupied) rates are around 8-8.5% last time I checked (probably with a point or 2 upfront I'd guess) compared to around 7.5% for a conventional primary residence loan or ~6.75-7% for a VA primary residence loan.

I'd recommend talking to both a lender who specializes in DSCR loans as well as someone who specializes in VA and conventional loans to compare options. I have some contacts for both in the DMV area if you need a recommendation. 

Post: Central MD REi Social

Kyle Deutschmann
Posted
  • Lender
  • Baltimore, MD
  • Posts 402
  • Votes 197
Quote from @Ali Ally:

How did I miss this? Was looking for meetup in DMV area. @Kyle Deutschmann, I did fill out the Google form but also wanted to voice a suggestion here to consider switching weekdays. I can’t make Wednesdays. Would love to attend any other day. Thanks for consideration! 

 I think @Jack Seiden and I were thinking of doing this every 2nd Thursday of the month. If anyone else has any suggested changes or other location suggestions please DM one of us. We chose Laurel since it's roughly halfway between DC, Baltimore, MoCo, and Annapolis. If you know of any local bars/restaurants/breweries in central MD with a space big enough for 25-35 guests we'd be happy to consider other locations.