Quote from @Jared Luhman:
I'm curious to hear people's thoughts. I would like to get into a lake house in northern Minnesota as a vacation rental and I'm currently looking at two options that are both about the same price and I want to know which people think would have the best income potential.
Option 1:
$310,000 for a 750 square foot 2 bedroom 1 bath on .3 acres right on a 100,000+acre lake. It needs updating and I have roughly $25,000 to spend which would make it very nice and updated. I could potentially put a small game room/arcade in one area of this house.
Option 2: $310,000 for a 1500 square foot 3 bedroom 2 bath on 1.3 acres on a 50 acre lake about 5 miles from the same big lake option 1 is on. So a much smaller lake but would be good for swimming/kayaking/paddle boarding. It has an attached garage plus a small separate garage/shop. This option is already nicely updated and my thoughts were to use the $25,000 to install a putting green in the yard and turn one of the garages into a nice arcade/game room and also install a hot tub and possibly some other nice amenities
I'm also open to hearing people tell me I shouldn't try either. But looking forward to hearing the thoughts.
Hey Jared,
Just my opinion as a born and raised MN boy. I would try to make the property on the bigger lake work. When we used to go up to the Brainard/Baxter area to visit my Grandparents in the summer and trailer our boat we would always rent a cabin on the whitefish chain or Gull lake.
A small lake limits some water activities, where as a large lake can accommodate anything. One would think that smaller lake means less boats but most of the time it really just means less water to share and harder to find your own peaceful area to fish or wakeboard etc... The growing popularity of wake surfing would also make me believe a larger body of water would be more attractive to lake enthusiasts. Winter time is ice fishing season, again I would think it would be easier for everyone to spread out and not feel as crammed together. I dont live in MN anymore but my family still lives on lake Minnetonka and one of my favorite things to do when I go back home is just go for a relaxing cruise on the shoreline with friends and fam, we can cruise that lake all day and not see half of it, smaller lakes dont really have that same effect.
Does the house on the larger lake have any room on the property to build? Or could you build a second level. That could be an awesome investment with the goal of value add by way of add on. Lakes only have so much shoreline property, if you can own a piece of that, that's almost guaranteed appreciation even if you never value add (value is in the land).
Taxes are definitely something to take into consideration. My family pays an unbelievable amount of taxes each year to live on that lake.
Good luck!